Telemachus makes this unmistakable. Odysseus had left behind an infant. He returned to find a young man. There was no recovering the childhood they had missed together. Odysseus could become Telemachus's father again - but he could never become the father who had been present while the boy was growing.
Penelope had changed as well. The young wife who watched her husband depart for Troy had spent twenty years managing uncertainty, protecting a household, resisting unwanted marriage, and living between hope and the possibility that Odysseus was dead. Whatever reunion awaited them would have to include the woman those years had made.
Even Odysseus could not return as the man who had left. The difference is written upon his body. When Eurycleia washes the stranger's feet, she discovers the scar Odysseus received from a boar hunt in his youth. Athena may disguise his appearance, years may alter his face, and clothing may conceal his station, but the scar has traveled with him.
It is an old wound carried by an older body. The scar does not prove that Odysseus has remained the same. It reveals something more interesting: a life can remain continuous while becoming different.
Penelope's recognition reaches even deeper. She does not finally trust Odysseus because others tell her who he is. She tests him with something belonging uniquely to their shared life. Their marriage bed. She orders that it be moved.
Yet Odysseus knows this is order is impossible without destroying what he built. The bed was fashioned around the trunk of a living olive tree. Its rootedness is the secret Penelope had been testing him to reveal. Only when he tells her does she recognize him.
The image of rootedness is nearly perfect for the homecoming Homer had constructed. The tree remained rooted while everything around it changed. So had something within their marriage.
But rootedness is not sameness. The years apart cannot be removed. Their losses cannot be reversed. The dead cannot be brought home with Odysseus. Penelope cannot become the young woman he left, nor Odysseus the young king who sailed for Troy. They can only meet as the people they have become.
Perhaps every homecoming eventually encounters this truth. We sometimes carry places and people inside memory as though they were protected from time. We imagine returning to them and finding what we left waiting for us. But home has been living and growing and dying and maturing while we were away.
Parents age. Children grow. Friends change. Houses weather. Relationships deepen, weaken, disappear, or take unfamiliar forms. The traveler changes too. No one returns to the world they left because there is no longer such a world to return to.
Yet this need not make homecoming impossible.
It simply changes what homecoming means.
The rooted olive bed does not erase twenty years. It gives Odysseus and Penelope something from those years that has endured and from which they might begin again. Homecoming therefore is not a voyage backward. It is a meeting in the present. Something has been preserved. Something has been lost. Something has changed. And something may still become.
Perhaps the question awaiting Odysseus and Penelope is the question awaiting every genuine return:
Given who we have become, what can we now become again together?
There comes a moment when winning must end.
This may be one of the hardest lessons for power to learn.
Power knows how to continue. Once awakened, it can find another enemy, another danger, another insult requiring answer. Every victory may expose another threat. Every injury may justify another retaliation. What began as defense can become vengeance, and vengeance can discover reasons to perpetuate itself.
By the end of The Odyssey, Odysseus has reclaimed his household. The suitors are dead. Penelope knows him. His authority has been restored. Yet the story does not end there. The dead suitors had fathers, brothers, relatives, and friends. Their deaths create new grief. And grief creates another possibility for violence.
The families of the slain gather against Odysseus. From their perspective, something terrible has happened in Ithaca. Whatever crimes the suitors committed, their bodies now lie dead, and those who loved them must live with what has followed. The danger is no longer that Odysseus will fail to regain his home. The danger is that Ithaca will continue destroying itself after he has regained it.
Homer brings us, therefore, to a problem different from the problem of war.
How does violence end?
Killing an enemy does not necessarily answer that question. It may only create another person who believes there is now someone else who must be killed.
One generation's vengeance can become another generation's inheritance.
The pattern is easy to understand. You harmed mine. Therefore I harm yours. My act then becomes the reason for your next act. Soon the original injury matters less than the accumulated injuries that followed it. Each side possesses its dead. Each possesses its reasons. Each remembers what the other has done. And everyone can claim that someone else began it.
This is how violence can outlive the circumstances that first produced it.
At the poem's end, Odysseus arms himself once more. Telemachus stands with him. Laertes joins them. Three generations of one family prepare to fight together. It could almost appear triumphant. But it should also trouble us. If grandfather, father, and son must continue killing together in order to preserve the household they have just recovered, what kind of homecoming has actually occurred?
Athena intervenes. The fighting must stop. The poem closes not with the annihilation of another enemy but with the interruption of retaliation and the restoration of peace.
This matters because restraint is not weakness.
Sometimes restraint requires a strength different from conquest.
It is relatively easy to understand power when power overcomes something. A wall falls. An enemy retreats. A threat is defeated. The result is visible. The power to stop is harder to measure. It requires recognizing that the ability to continue does not by itself provide a reason to continue.
A person may have the strength to retaliate and choose not to. A nation may have the ability to humiliate a defeated enemy and refuse to do so. A parent may possess authority and decide that authority need not be exercised to its limit. A victorious person may discover that having the final word is less important than allowing a relationship to survive.
Such restraint does not deny power.
It governs power.
And perhaps power becomes most dangerous when nothing within it can say, Enough.
Odysseus has spent much of his life learning how to overcome obstacles. At Ithaca he encounters a different challenge. The restored king must inhabit a community with people who have reasons to hate him. He cannot kill everyone who grieves for those he killed. At some point, a shared world must become more important than another victory.
That does not erase wrongdoing. It does not require pretending that justice and injustice are indistinguishable. It simply recognizes that justice cannot consist forever in producing another body for someone else to avenge. There must come a moment when the weapon is lowered. When victory is sufficient. When the living are allowed to continue living.
Perhaps this is the final discipline of power:
not merely knowing when it can prevail,
but knowing when the future requires violence to stop.
At the beginning there was a ship leaving home.
Now there is a man standing again upon the soil from which he departed.
Between those moments lies nearly everything Homer could place in his path: war and wandering, beauty and terror, cunning and failure, loyalty and betrayal, longing and loss. Odysseus crossed a world filled with lives other than his own and returned carrying the consequences of having lived among them.
But the story does not return him to the beginning. It cannot. The young warrior who sailed for Troy is gone. The infant Telemachus is gone. The Penelope who watched the ships disappear is gone. Many who left with Odysseus will never see Ithaca again.
The journey has become part of everyone who survived it.
And now another journey begins.
Telemachus will live beyond the final lines of Homer's poem. Whatever world Odysseus and Penelope restore will become part of the world their son inherits. The peace established at Ithaca will either endure, deepen, fracture, or be remade by those who come afterward.
Homer does not tell us. Perhaps he does not need to. Every story must eventually release its characters into a future the storyteller does not describe.
So must every generation.
We spend our lives inside worlds handed to us by people who themselves once inherited worlds from others. Some left us knowledge. Some left institutions. Some planted orchards whose fruit they would never eat. Some left wounds still requiring attention. Some preserved stories so that people centuries later might learn something from lives long ended.
We do the same. Much of what we leave behind will not carry our names. Someone may benefit from a kindness without remembering who offered it. A child may inherit a possibility created by someone who died generations earlier. A repaired relationship may change a family in ways no participant lives long enough to see. A decision to stop an old injury from traveling farther may spare people who will never know there was once an injury to inherit.
This is one of the strange privileges of being human.
We participate in futures we will never see.
The question, then, is not whether we leave a world to others. We will. The question is what kind of world our participation helps leave behind. Perhaps this is where our journey with Homer finally returns to the image with which homecoming began.
The olive tree remains rooted beneath the marriage bed.
Long before Odysseus went to Troy, it was growing from Ithacan soil. Odysseus built around it rather than cutting it down. The living tree became part of the house, part of the marriage, part of the secret by which Penelope would someday recognize the man who returned.
Years passed. War came. The household suffered. People aged. Some died. Still the tree grew. There is something quietly beautiful in that. Human beings do not create the world from nothing. We build within something already living. We receive what was growing before us and decide, for a time, what we will build around it. Then eventually our hands leave the work. Others will continue our work.
This may be why homecoming provides such a fitting end to The Odyssey. Home is not simply where the traveler stops. Home is where the traveler must learn again that life is shared.That the world contains other people. Their suffering matters. Their hopes matter. Their freedom matters. Their becoming matters. And whatever reality finally is, we find ourselves already within it, participating in what it becomes.
Six essays ago, we began with a journey. We followed a man across the sea because he wanted to go home. Along the way, the journey became larger than the traveler. It became a story about becoming, reality, relationship, war, memory, power, inheritance, responsibility, and the difficult possibility of learning to live together. Now the ships may finally disappear beyond the horizon. Odysseus has reached Ithaca. Homer has told his story. And we have heard it.
The story can no longer tell us exactly what to do. No ancient poem can live our lives for us. The world before us is not Homer's world, and the journeys awaiting us will be our own.
But perhaps an old story can still place a question into our keeping. We have inherited a world we did not make. For a little while, it passes through our hands. Others will receive what follows. And so the journey ends where living must always begin:
How then shall we live?
Perhaps with this:
Live in such a way that others can live, too.
Homer. The Iliad. Translated by Emily Wilson. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2023.
Homer. The Odyssey. Translated by Emily Wilson. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2018.
Nagy, Gregory. The Ancient Greek Hero in 24 Hours. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2013.
Shay, Jonathan. Achilles in Vietnam: Combat Trauma and the Undoing of Character. New York: Scribner, 1994.
Shay, Jonathan. Odysseus in America: Combat Trauma and the Trials of Homecoming. New York: Scribner, 2002.
West, M. L. The Making of the Odyssey. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.
No comments:
Post a Comment