In Part 1, we asked whether Christianity made the world more moral or not? Our conclusion was:
Morality is as old as humanity itself. Ethics is the reflection on how best to live together. What Christianity did was to tie these deeply and explicitly to worship of a God who cares about how people treat one another — including outsiders. Whether this made the world more moral is debatable — but it certainly reshaped how moral behavior was taught, justified, and spread.
Then, in Part 2, we then asked whether Christianity had failed it's own morality tests? We decided there that:
Where Christianity stayed close to the radical moral teachings of Jesus founded on love, it has inspired profound good. But where Christianity marries itself to power, it often contradicts its own moral heart.
Now here, in Part 3, let's ask whether there are worldly philosophies which have influenced religious and societal morality and ethics for better or worse?
Let's begin...Short answer: Yes — many non-religious or semi-religious philosophies have profoundly shaped how societies (including religious societies) define good and bad, justice and injustice, rights and duties. They’ve influenced morality for better and worse.
Below is a brief map of some major philosophical traditions and their impact.
1️⃣ Greek Philosophy (Classical)
-
Who: Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Stoics.
-
Core Ideas: Virtue ethics (what kind of person should I become?), reason as guide to the good life, moral duty to the polis (community).
-
Impact: Deeply influenced Christian ethics (e.g., Aquinas merged Aristotle’s virtue ethics with Christian teaching). Stoicism inspired later Christian ideas of self-control, endurance, and moral integrity.
2️⃣ Roman Civic Philosophy
-
Who: Cicero, Seneca.
-
Core Ideas: Natural law — the idea that there’s a universal moral order knowable by reason. Duty to society and the common good.
-
Impact: Shaped medieval and modern concepts of universal human rights, which the church adopted into canon law. Influenced Enlightenment thinkers.
3️⃣ Confucianism
-
Who: Confucius, Mencius.
-
Core Ideas: Right relationships, filial piety, respect for hierarchy, moral cultivation through ritual and tradition.
-
Impact: Has shaped East Asian societies for millennia — family-centered ethics, community harmony. Sometimes limited by rigid hierarchies, but its influence on communal responsibility remains profound.
4️⃣ Enlightenment Rationalism & Secular Humanism
-
Who: Locke, Voltaire, Rousseau, Kant.
-
Core Ideas: Individual rights, freedom of conscience, moral autonomy, reason over tradition.
-
Impact: Challenged church authority, helped birth modern democracies, abolitionism, universal education. Also fueled secularization — sometimes clashing with religious moral authority.
5️⃣ Marxism
-
Who: Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels.
-
Core Ideas: Economic justice, critique of class exploitation, call for equality.
-
Impact: Inspired liberation theology in Latin America — merging Christian concern for the poor with radical social critique. Also justified oppressive regimes when misapplied dogmatically.
6️⃣ Utilitarianism
-
Who: Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill.
-
Core Ideas: The greatest good for the greatest number — morality judged by outcomes, not rules.
-
Impact: Influenced modern law, economics, healthcare ethics. Sometimes clashes with religious absolute principles.
7️⃣ Existentialism
-
Who: Kierkegaard (Christian existentialist), Nietzsche, Sartre.
-
Core Ideas: Individual responsibility to define one’s own meaning. Authenticity over conformity.
-
Impact: Kierkegaard deepened Christian interior ethics. Nietzsche’s “God is dead” critique provoked churches to rethink stale moralism. Existentialist freedom influenced postmodern pluralism ( = equality for all races, genders, sexes, and religions vs majority control of nationalized supremacists).
8️⃣ Postmodern Critical Theories
-
Who: Foucault, Derrida.
-
Core Ideas: Questioning all grand narratives, including moral absolutes. Power shapes “truth”.
-
Impact: Helped uncover injustices hidden by traditional moral authorities (colonialism, patriarchy). Also fuels moral relativism that some see as eroding shared values.
✅ Better or Worse?
Better:
-
Expanded rights (abolition, women’s suffrage, civil rights).
-
Secular checks on religious abuses of power.
-
New moral frameworks for pluralistic societies.
Worse:
-
When severed from a moral compass, some philosophies justified cruelty (totalitarian communism, radical relativism).
-
Some eroded community bonds when hyper-individualism displaced shared duties.
🧭 Big takeaway
Religious morality and worldly philosophy have never been separate islands — they continually reshape each other, sometimes in creative tension, sometimes in conflict. The healthiest moral cultures often draw on both — the spiritual why and the philosophical how.