Quotes & Sayings


We, and creation itself, actualize the possibilities of the God who sustains the world, becoming more fully within the continuing life of creation. - R.E. Slater

There is urgency in coming to see the world as a web of interrelated processes of which we are integral parts, so that all of our choices and actions have [consequential effects upon] the world around us. - Process Metaphysician Alfred North Whitehead

Kurt Gödel's Incompleteness Theorem says (i) all closed systems are unprovable within themselves and, that (ii) all open systems are rightly understood as incomplete. - R.E. Slater

The most true thing about you is what God has said to you in Christ, "You are My Beloved." - Tripp Fuller

The God among us is the God who refuses to be God without us, so great is God's Love. - Tripp Fuller

According to some Christian outlooks we were made for another world. Perhaps, rather, we were made for this world to recreate, reclaim, redeem, and renew unto God's future aspiration by the power of His Spirit. - R.E. Slater

Our eschatological ethos is to love. To stand with those who are oppressed. To stand against those who are oppressing. It is that simple. Love is our only calling and Christian Hope. - R.E. Slater

Secularization theory has been massively falsified. We don't live in an age of secularity. We live in an age of explosive, pervasive religiosity... an age of religious pluralism. - Peter L. Berger

Exploring the edge of life and faith in a post-everything world. - Todd Littleton

I don't need another reason to believe, your love is all around for me to see. – Anon

Thou art our need; and in giving us more of thyself thou givest us all. - Khalil Gibran, Prayer XXIII

Be careful what you pretend to be. You become what you pretend to be. - Kurt Vonnegut

Religious beliefs, far from being primary, are often shaped and adjusted by our social goals. - Jim Forest

We become who we are by what we believe and can justify. - R.E. Slater

People, even more than things, need to be restored, renewed, revived, reclaimed, and redeemed; never throw out anyone. – Anon

Certainly, God's love has made fools of us all. - R.E. Slater

An apocalyptic Christian faith doesn't wait for Jesus to come, but for Jesus to become in our midst. - R.E. Slater

Christian belief in God begins with the cross and resurrection of Jesus, not with rational apologetics. - Eberhard Jüngel, Jürgen Moltmann

Our knowledge of God is through the 'I-Thou' encounter, not in finding God at the end of a syllogism or argument. There is a grave danger in any Christian treatment of God as an object. The God of Jesus Christ and Scripture is irreducibly subject and never made as an object, a force, a power, or a principle that can be manipulated. - Emil Brunner

“Ehyeh Asher Ehyeh” means "I will be that who I have yet to become." - God (Ex 3.14) or, conversely, “I AM who I AM Becoming.”

Our job is to love others without stopping to inquire whether or not they are worthy. - Thomas Merton

The church is God's world-changing social experiment of bringing unlikes and differents to the Eucharist/Communion table to share life with one another as a new kind of family. When this happens, we show to the world what love, justice, peace, reconciliation, and life together is designed by God to be. The church is God's show-and-tell for the world to see how God wants us to live as a blended, global, polypluralistic family united with one will, by one Lord, and baptized by one Spirit. – Anon

The cross that is planted at the heart of the history of the world cannot be uprooted. - Jacques Ellul

The Unity in whose loving presence the universe unfolds is inside each person as a call to welcome the stranger, protect animals and the earth, respect the dignity of each person, think new thoughts, and help bring about ecological civilizations. - John Cobb & Farhan A. Shah

If you board the wrong train it is of no use running along the corridors of the train in the other direction. - Dietrich Bonhoeffer

God's justice is restorative rather than punitive; His discipline is merciful rather than punishing; His power is made perfect in weakness; and His grace is sufficient for all. – Anon

Our little [biblical] systems have their day; they have their day and cease to be. They are but broken lights of Thee, and Thou, O God art more than they. - Alfred Lord Tennyson

We can’t control God; God is uncontrollable. God can’t control us; God’s love is uncontrolling! - Thomas Jay Oord

Life in perspective but always in process... as we are relational beings in process to one another, so life events are in process in relation to each event... as God is to Self, is to world, is to us... like Father, like sons and daughters, like events... life in process yet always in perspective. - R.E. Slater

To promote societal transition to sustainable ways of living and a global society founded on a shared ethical framework which includes respect and care for the community of life, ecological integrity, universal human rights, respect for diversity, economic justice, democracy, and a culture of peace. - The Earth Charter Mission Statement

Christian humanism is the belief that human freedom, individual conscience, and unencumbered rational inquiry are compatible with the practice of Christianity or even intrinsic in its doctrine. It represents a philosophical union of Christian faith and classical humanist principles. - Scott Postma

It is never wise to have a self-appointed religious institution determine a nation's moral code. The opportunities for moral compromise and failure are high; the moral codes and creeds assuredly racist, discriminatory, or subjectively and religiously defined; and the pronouncement of inhumanitarian political objectives quite predictable. - R.E. Slater

God's love must both center and define the Christian faith and all religious or human faiths seeking human and ecological balance in worlds of subtraction, harm, tragedy, and evil. - R.E. Slater

Without Love there is no Truth. And True Truth is always Loving. There is no dichotomy between these terms but only seamless integration. This is the premier centering focus of a Processual Theology of Love. - R.E. Slater

-----

Note: Generally I do not respond to commentary. I may read the comments but wish to reserve my time to write (or write from the comments I read). Instead, I'd like to see our community help one another and in the helping encourage and exhort each of us towards Christian love in Christ Jesus our Lord and Savior. - re slater

Friday, September 18, 2026

Index - Prehistory of the Bible



Index - Prehistory of the Bible

An Introductory Study into the Deep Human World Behind the Bible

by R.E. Slater and ChatGPT

The question being asked in this study, “How then shall we live?” is an inadvertent echo of Francis Schaeffer's "How Should We Then Live?" - the title of his 1976 book and associated film series, "How Should We Then Live? The Rise and Decline of Western Thought and Culture." The question emerged from the intellectual world surrounding Schaeffer's residential study center, L'Abri in Switzerland, and from his attempt to trace Western civilization through philosophy, art, religion, and culture toward what he regarded as the crisis of modern secular thought.

More than half a century later, we have approached a similar question, but through a considerably longer human history - one extending beyond Western civilization, Christianity, Israel, and the biblical page into the evolutionary and prehistoric worlds from which human culture itself emerged. Our question therefore becomes not only how Christians might live within a modern pluralistic world, but how human beings, having inherited this immense evolutionary, cultural, religious, and narrative history, might live more responsibly and compassionately with one another, with the stranger, and with the living world of nature with which we share.

 


Introduction to the Series

Long before there was a Bible, there were human beings asking questions. They wondered about birth and death, the heavens and Earth, animals and ancestors, suffering and catastrophe, good and evil, belonging and the stranger, and whatever powers or mysteries might lie beyond the visible world. For tens of thousands of years these questions found expression through burial, ritual, art, symbol, story, myth, religion, and eventually written literature.

The Prehistory of the Bible essays will explore this largely forgotten world behind the Bible. Beginning with human evolution and the symbolic cultures of the Paleolithic, Mesolithic, and Neolithic periods, the study moves forward through the rise of agriculture, cities, civilizations, and the great narrative traditions of Mesopotamia, Egypt, Canaan, and the ancient Near East. Only then do we arrive at ancient Israel and discover that the Bible did not simply appear in an empty world with its own early events and beliefs. Rather, its stories participated in an already ancient human conversation about creation, climate events, mortality, catastrophe, justice, suffering, God, community, and the meaning of human existence.

This historical study is not intended to disprove God, diminish the Bible, or submit faith to a scientific test. The foundational companion essays clarify the philosophical and theological position from which the study proceeds. The principal historical excavation then brackets questions of revelation, inspiration, and inerrancy while reconstructing the evolutionary, archaeological, cultural, religious, and literary worlds behind the Bible. Those theological questions return in fuller form only after the historical work has been undertaken.

Its historical purpose remains fundamental: to give the Bible back its historical background. Its larger theological purpose is to ask how Christian faith may remain intellectually honest and spiritually alive after that background has been restored. When Scriptural understanding is integrated with the prehistory of civilization before it - the evolutionary, cultural, religious, and later literary worlds from which it arose - then familiar biblical texts may become unfamiliar again, and perhaps richer for the discussion.

The God of the universe, of the heavens and the earth, may be a question for some, but for many this God is ever a wonder and a mystery. As the earth and ancient life evolved, early humanity gradually became capable of asking ancient questions of God and life. Those questions, insights, beliefs, and stories became part of humanity’s enduring cultural inheritance that were remembered not only then but even now, in our modern, postmodern, and emerging metamodern societies as we search for meaning and meaningful living with one another.

That ancient search eventually returns the question to us. What have human beings learned across the immense journey from our earliest ancestors to the present? How might our inherited stories help us become more compassionate participants in the world we now inhabit? The journey into biblical prehistory therefore leads finally toward the present: toward care for one another, hospitality toward the stranger, compassion for suffering, responsibility toward Earth and its wild things, and the continuing question that has accompanied humanity from time immemorial: How then shall we live?

 


The Immediate World Behind the Bible
The Ancient Narrative World Israel Inherited and Reinterpreted


Ancient
source/tradition
Approx. surviving
textual tradition

Biblical resonance
Enuma Elish2nd millennium BCEGenesis 1; creation, primordial waters, cosmic ordering
Atrahasis Epicc. 18th–17th c. BCEGenesis 1–9; creation of humans, overpopulation, divine judgment, flood
Epic of Gilgamesh, Tablet XIroots in 2nd millennium BCEGenesis 6–9; flood, boat, preservation of life, birds, sacrifice
Sumerian Flood / Ziusudraearly 2nd millennium BCE textNoah tradition
Eridu Genesis traditionsSumeriancreation → kingship → flood
Adapa2nd millennium BCEmortality, divine knowledge, lost possibility of immortality
Enki and Ninhursag / DilmunSumerianparadisal land, water, fertility, human/divine existence
Enki and NinmahSumeriancreation of humanity from clay
Egyptian creation traditions3rd–1st millennia BCEprimordial waters, creation by divine speech/order
Ugaritic Baal Cyclec. 14th–13th c. BCEPsalms, Job, prophetic imagery; storm deity, sea/chaos combat
Aqhat / Keret traditionsUgaritickingship, blessing, fertility, covenantal/social themes
Mesopotamian law collections3rd–2nd millennia BCEExodus–Deuteronomy; covenant/law/social order
Egyptian wisdom literature3rd–1st millennia BCEProverbs, Ecclesiastes and wisdom traditions
Babylonian Theodicy / Ludlul2nd millennium BCEJob; innocent suffering and divine justice

1 - The flood relationship is particularly strong. Comparative scholarship treats Atrahasis, the Sumerian flood account, Gilgamesh, and later Berossus as genuine comparative material for Genesis 6–8, while also emphasizing that similarities must be weighed rather than merely counted.

2 - Ancient human questions were already asking about creation, flood, chaos, garden, mortality, divine-human relations, sacrifice, kingship, law, wisdom, suffering.



A Provisional Outline for the
Prehistory of the Bible Study Series


Long before there was Scripture,
there were human beings asking questions.

The Bible did not begin humanity's great conversation.
It entered into it.

When did reality first become story in the human mind -
and why did those stories develop?

Ultimately, humanity comes to ask,
"How then shall we live?"

- R.E. Slater and ChatGPT



Prelude to Relational Faith

Before beginning our formal historical study of biblical prehistory, these eight introductory essays establish the scientific, philosophical, historical, interpretive, and theological orientation of the project. They examine humanity's evolutionary and religious ancestry before asking whether Christian faith can remain intellectually responsible within an open and developing world. Relational philosophy remains independent of Christian theology, while theological interpretations remain open to historical and philosophical criticism.

Faith, Scholarship, and God Within Relational Reality
Establishing the philosophical and methodological foundations of the project. Distinguishing reality, ontology, metaphysics, interpretation, theology, and Christian confession without isolating them from one another. Relational philosophy is introduced as an independent inquiry into reality rather than a means of demonstrating Christian belief.

Common Ancestry, Hominin Diversity, and What Human Evolution Actually Means
Recovering humanity's evolutionary history through common ancestry, hominin diversity, adaptation, migration, and biological development. Scientific evidence is examined on its own terms before philosophical or theological interpretation is introduced.

Evolutionary Becoming, Christian Faith, and Humanity Within an Evolving Creation
Considering humanity's evolutionary emergence through relational philosophy and Christian theological interpretation. Human beings are understood as embodied participants within an evolving natural world rather than organisms standing apart from it.

Before History Remembered Us (3)
The Lost Worlds of Humanity’s Deep Prehistory
Recovering the prehistoric worlds of human evolution, sociality, cultural development, symbolic imagination, ritual behavior, and the possible emergence of religious interpretation before written history.

Hominins, Changing Climates, Migration, and Social Becoming

Encountering the Symbolic World of the Paleolithic (3b)
Language, Memory, Imagination, Death, and the Expanding Human World

Ritual, Spirit, Story, and the Ancient Worlds of Human Meaning

When Ancient Peoples Imagined the Beginning (4)
Myth, Memory, History, and the Making of Biblical Origins
Tracing the development of settlement, institutional religion, mythology, writing, and sacred authority. Examining the ancient Near Eastern religious worlds from which biblical traditions emerged and how inherited narratives became authoritative Scripture.

Essay 4A - Sections I–IV
From Prehistoric Religion to the Institutional Development of Religion. 

From Named Gods to the Ancient Near Eastern Conversation.
 
Essay 4C - Sections IX–XIV
From Common Human Questions to Sacred Scripture, followed by the Conclusion and supporting materials.

From Religious Inheritance to Living Religion (5)
How Inherited Religious Worlds Become Living Systems of Belief
Examining how religious narratives, rituals, memories, institutions, and claims of divine authority become enduring systems of belief. Distinguishing the historical development of religious traditions from theological claims concerning divine reality.

From Religious Inheritance to Living Belief. Examining how inherited narratives, rituals, memories, and religious experiences develop into shared understandings of sacred reality.

From Living Belief to Religious Authority. Exploring how religious traditions become institutionalized, transmitted, interpreted, and invested with sacred authority across generations.

From Historical Explanation to the Question of Divine Reality. Distinguishing the historical development of religious belief from theological claims concerning God, revelation, and the possibility of continuing Christian faith.

Tools to Deconstruct and Construct a Religious Faith (Part I)
Examining the consequences of historical criticism for inherited Christian beliefs concerning Scripture, revelation, religious authority, and God. Asking what convictions may be retained, revised, relinquished, or reconsidered, and whether responsible Christian faith remains possible without a closed explanatory system.

Toward a Relational Christian Theology (7)
Tools to Deconstruct and Construct a Religious Faith (Part II)
Exploring a constructive Christian theology through relational philosophy, panentheism, divine presence, creation, revelation, Jesus Christ, resurrection, salvation, suffering, and hope. Considering God as love while preserving the independence of relational philosophy and requiring theological claims to be critically defended.



Toward a Relational Christian Theology:
Conclusion & Appendices
(7c)

Relational Theology and the Christian Worldview (8)
Can Relational Theology Serve as a Comprehensive Christian Worldview
Without Compromising the Independence of Relational Philosophy or the Christian Faith?
Examining whether relational philosophy, historical scholarship, Christian theology, ethics, and practical participation can contribute to a comprehensive and critically revisable Christian worldview. Returning to humanity's enduring questions concerning existence, life, suffering, community, and the powers governing human survival.

Conclusion - From the Prelude to Biblical Prehistory
These essays establish the philosophical, historical, and theological orientation for the larger study without predetermining its findings. We now begin our historical excavation, moving backward from the Bible we have inherited through ancient religion and human prehistory before returning to Scripture within its immense human ancestry.


Reality → Ontology → Metaphysics → Interpretation → Theology → Ethics → Participation



Introduction - The Prehistory of the Bible

The Prehistory of the Bible (9) --- adjust numbering order through remaining series ---
An Introductory Study into the Deep Human World Behind the Bible
Long before there was a Bible, human beings were already confronting birth and death, animals and ancestors, catastrophe and survival, belonging and the stranger, the heavens and Earth, suffering and meaning, and whatever powers or mysteries might lie beyond the immediately visible world. This introductory essay establishes the purpose of the study: not to disprove God, diminish Scripture, or test anyone's faith, but to recover the immense evolutionary, archaeological, cultural, religious, historical, and literary worlds behind the Bible.

The Bible Has an Address (8)
Returning Scripture to History
The Bible arose somewhere, sometime, among particular peoples speaking particular languages and inhabiting particular cultural, political, cosmological, and religious worlds. To understand Scripture historically is therefore to give the Bible back its originating address.

Excavating the Human Story (10)
Evidence, Archaeology, Text, Interpretation, and the Limits of Knowing
Introducing the method of the series. We begin in the present and excavate backward through Christianity, Judaism, ancient Israel, neighboring civilizations, prehistoric cultures, and human evolution. Along the way we distinguish: evidence → inference → interpretation → speculation. Texts can sometimes tell us what ancient people said. Archaeology can tell us what people made and did. Neither automatically tells us everything they believed.


The Architecture of Biblical Prehistory
Phase 1 - The Excavation

Where did the Bible come from? Our first journey moves backward. We begin with the biblical world familiar to contemporary Christians and progressively remove later historical layers. Each excavation raises the same question: What lies beneath this portion of history?

Movement I - The Bible We Inherited
Beginning Where We Are to the Deep Human Past

The Bible Christians Think They Know (11)
Scripture, Memory, and Inherited Belief
Creation, Adam and Eve, the Fall, Flood, Babel, Abraham, Israel, Satan, Messiah, heaven, hell, resurrection, Jesus, and Christ as they commonly inhabit Christian imagination. Before asking whether these understandings are correct or incorrect, we must first ask how they came to be understood in their present forms.

Biblical Belief and Christian Belief (12)
Are The Two Always the Same Thing?
Ancient biblical ideas and later Christian beliefs are related but not necessarily identical. Centuries of theology, philosophy, doctrine, translation, preaching, art, culture, and tradition can become unconsciously read backward into much older texts.

Where Did These Ideas Come From? (13)
Beginning the Excavation
How old are the beliefs Christians commonly associate with the Bible? Which forms of those beliefs come from the Hebrew Bible? Which forms developed within later Judaism? Which arose within Christianity? And which acquired their familiar forms much later still?

Movement II - Beneath Christianity
Jesus and the Jewish Worlds Behind Christian Belief

Jesus Was a Jew (14)
Recovering the Historical World of Jesus
Jesus as located within Second Temple Judaism rather than in later Christianity: Torah, Temple, Roman occupation, Jewish sectarian diversity, prophetic tradition, wisdom, apocalyptic expectation, purity, poverty, power, and hope.

The Jewish World Before Christianity (15)
Temple, Torah, Wisdom, and Apocalyptic Hope
The diverse Jewish religious worlds preceding and surrounding the Jesus movement. Judaism itself possessed a history.

Messiah, Resurrection, Angels, Demons, and Satan (16)
Ancient Ideas With Their Own Histories
Concepts often assumed to be uniformly biblical developed substantially across Jewish history, especially during the Second Temple period. Religious ideas themselves become part of our archaeological excavation.

From Jesus to Messiah (Christ) (17)
History, Memory, Confession, and Interpretation
Jesus belongs to history. Jesus as Messiah Christ belongs to interpretation. How communities remembering Jesus interpreted his life, teaching, crucifixion, resurrection experiences, and continuing significance through Jewish categories such as Messiah, Lord, Son of Man, Son of God, and eventually other philosophical and theological categories.

Movement III - Beneath Judaism
Ancient Israel and the Becoming of Biblical Religion

Before Judaism (18)
Israel and Judah in the Ancient Near East
Moving backward from Second Temple Judaism into the older worlds of Israel and Judah. Who were the Israelites, and where did they belong within the ancient Near East?

Yahweh, El, and the Divine World of Ancient Israel (19)
Recovering an Older Religious Landscape
Israelite religion within its wider Canaanite setting. The religious cults of Yahweh, El, Asherah, divine councils, local cults, family religion, temples, shrines, and the evidence for a religious world more complex than later monotheistic summaries sometimes suggest.

From Many Gods Towards One God (20)
The Long Development of Israelite Monotheism
Polytheistic environments, monolatry, exclusive Yahwism, exile, theological reinterpretation, and the development of increasingly explicit monotheism.

Temple, Sacrifice, Kingship, and Prophecy (21)
Religion Before the Bible Became a Book
Israelite religion as lived practice before it became primarily encountered by later readers as written Scripture.

Exile and the Remaking of Israel (22)
Catastrophe, Memory, Identity, and God
How conquest, destruction, displacement, exile, and restoration reshaped Israel's understanding of itself, its past, its covenant, and its God.

How the Hebrew Bible Became (23)
Memory, Oral Tradition, Writing, Editing, and Scripture
The long movement from remembered traditions and oral transmission through written compositions, collections, revisions, and eventual bodies of authoritative literature.

Movement IV - The Great Civilizations Behind the Bible
The Bible itself has a history

Israel Had Neighbors (24)
Entering the Ancient Near Eastern World
Israel did not arise in an empty cultural landscape. Introduction to Canaan, Ugarit, Egypt, Sumer, Akkad, Assyria, and Babylon.

Sumer, Akkad, and Babylon (25)
Stories Older Than the Bible
Cities, writing, scribes, temples, kings, gods, creation, catastrophe, mortality, law, wisdom, and the emergence of written narrative traditions long before biblical literature.

Egypt and the Ordered Cosmos (26)
Creation, Ma'at, Kingship, Death, and Eternity
Primordial waters, divine creativity, cosmic order, sacred kingship, wisdom, death, judgment, and afterlife.

Canaan and Ugarit (27)
The Religious World Closest to Ancient Israel
El, Baal, Asherah, Anat, divine councils, sacred mountains, Sea, Death, storm imagery, fertility, and kingship. Here we encounter some of the cultural and religious worlds most closely related to ancient Israel.

Before Genesis (28)
Ancient Stories of Creation and Human Origins
Enuma Elish, Atrahasis, Egyptian creation traditions, humans from earthly materials, primordial waters, divine speech, cosmic ordering, sacred landscapes, and humanity's place within creation.

Before Noah (29)
Flood, Catastrophe, Climate, and Cultural Memory
Ziusudra, Atrahasis, Gilgamesh, ancient flood traditions, environmental catastrophe, cultural memory, and the later biblical flood narrative. Similarity does not automatically mean copying. The task is to understand inheritance, shared environment, adaptation, transformation, and literary relationship where evidence permits.

Gardens, Wisdom, Serpents, and Immortality (30)
Ancient Humanity Confronts Mortality
Adapa, Gilgamesh, Dilmun, sacred gardens, wisdom, lost immortality, life, death, and humanity's ancient awareness of its mortality.

Law, Justice, Suffering, and Wisdom (31)
Human Questions Before Biblical Answers
Mesopotamian law collections, Egyptian wisdom traditions, Babylonian theodicy, lament, innocent suffering, justice, social order, and their biblical resonances.


Interlude I
Humanity's Questions Before the Bible

Before there was Genesis, humanity was already asking:
  • Where did everything come from?
  • Why are we here?
  • Why do humans die?
  • Why is there suffering?
  • Why does catastrophe occur?
  • What makes something sacred?
  • What do we owe one another?
  • What do we owe the dead?
  • What lies beyond the visible world?
  • How should we live?
But writing only takes us so far. We dig deeper.

Movement V - Beneath Civilization
The Neolithic and Mesolithic Worlds of Early Humanity

When Writing Disappears (32)
How Can We Know What Prehistoric Humans Believed?
We cross an evidentiary boundary. There are no texts to explain what people thought. Archaeology becomes our principal witness: buildings, bodies, burials, objects, images, food, landscapes, deposition, and repeated human behavior.

Göbekli Tepe (33)
Gathering, Monument, Animal, and Symbol Before Civilization
Monumental architecture among hunter-gatherer and early sedentary communities at the beginning of the Neolithic. What can its pillars, animals, enclosures, and gathering practices tell us - and what may remain unknown?

Houses, Ancestors, and the Dead (34)
Çatalhöyük, Jericho, 'Ain Ghazal, and Neolithic Meaning
Burials beneath houses, plastered skulls, anthropomorphic statues, animals, domestic spaces, ancestors, community, and memory.

Agriculture Changed Everything (35)
Land, Settlement, Fertility, Property, and Power
The Neolithic transformation of humanity's relationship with land, animals, food, reproduction, settlement, property, hierarchy, community, and sacred spaces.

Before the Farmers (36)
Mesolithic Worlds of Landscape, Animals, and Memory
Hunter-gatherer worlds during changing post-Ice Age environments. Burial, ornamentation, animals, landscape, mobility, repeated places, ancestors, and community. Cities disappear. Writing disappears. 
Agriculture largely disappears. But meaning does not disappear.

Movement VI - Beneath Religion
Paleolithic Humanity and the First Symbolic Worlds

The Living and the Dead (37)
Middle Paleolithic Humanity and the Human Threshold
Early Homo sapiens, Neanderthals, deliberate burial, ochre, ornaments, possible symbolic markings, care for bodies, and the increasingly hazardous attempt to infer ancient meanings. We do not know whether these people possessed "religion." But something was happening.

When Humans Began Leaving Symbols (38)
The Archaeology of Meaning
Material evidence for representation, identity, memory, symbolic behavior, and increasingly complex cultural worlds.

Into the Caves (39)
Chauvet, Lascaux, Altamira, and the Painted Animal World
Deep-cave imagery, animals, handprints, abstract signs, difficult subterranean spaces, and the extraordinary investment humans made in creating images far from ordinary habitation.

The Lion-Man and the Imagined World (40)
When Reality Became More Than What Was Seen
Human-animal composites, figurines, representation, imagination, and humanity's growing capacity to create things that had never existed in ordinary perception. Human beings were no longer merely inhabiting reality. They were visibly interpreting it.


Interlude II
When Did Reality Become Story?

At some unknowable point, a human ancestor confronted death, birth, blood, animal, fire, lightning, moon, storm, darkness, or another human being and did something astonishing: s/he wondered what it meant. That moment left no text. Yet much of what followed may depend upon capacities such moments reveal.

Movement VII - Beneath Story
Evolution and the Becoming of Humanity

Becoming Human (41)
Evolution Before Religion
The much deeper evolutionary history behind Homo sapiens. Hominin evolution and the emergence of creatures increasingly capable of social learning, culture, memory, communication, imagination, and symbolic life.

Human Beings Became Human Together (42)
Sociality, Cooperation, Competition, and Care
Attachment, kinship, caregiving, food sharing, reciprocity, cooperation, conflict, violence, group belonging, and the evolutionary roots of human social existence. Religion did not invent sociality. Narrative did not invent cooperation. Both eventually worked upon capacities with much deeper evolutionary histories.

From Communication to Symbol (43)
Language, Memory, Imagination, and Shared Meaning
How increasingly sophisticated communication, social learning, memory, imagination, and symbolic cognition made cumulative culture possible.

Before Myth (44)
The First Symbolic Horizon
A cautious conceptual exploration: awareness → agency → death → memory → symbol → ritual → shared narrative → myth → cosmology → religion. Not an inevitable evolutionary ladder and not a reconstructed chronology of prehistoric belief. Rather, these are capacities and developments through which evolutionary humans became capable of constructing shared worlds of meaning. We have now reached the deepest layer of our excavation. Now we turn around and move back up the ladder of time.


The Architecture of Biblical Prehistory
Phase 2 - The Long Human Journey

Having excavated backward through the historical layers beneath the Bible, we now reconstruct humanity's development in its chronological direction, from evolutionary origins toward the emergence of biblical literature. The first phase asked: What lies beneath the Bible? The second asks: What happened across this immense span of human time? We now reconstruct the history in its natural chronological direction. The purpose is not to repeat the excavation. It is to see development, continuity, discontinuity, and transformation across time.

Movement VIII - From Human Becoming to Human Meaning
The Chronological Reconstruction

The Deep Human Beginning (45)
Evolution, Sociality, Care, and the Emergence of Homo sapiens
Beginning at the evolutionary foundation: embodied social creatures living, cooperating, competing, reproducing, learning, caring, communicating, and surviving together.

The First Symbolic Horizons (46)
Middle Paleolithic Humanity
Roughly 300,000-50,000 years ago. Early Homo sapiens, Neanderthals, bodies, ochre, ornament, burial, identity, social memory, and the first increasingly visible traces of symbolic worlds.

When Reality Became Story (47)
Upper Paleolithic Humanity
Roughly 50,000-12,000 BCE. Cave imagery, animals, composite beings, figurines, ornaments, burial, signs, representation, imagination, and increasingly elaborate symbolic culture.

Between the Ice Age and Early Agricultural Societies (48)
Mesolithic Humanity
Roughly 15,000-8,000 BCE, varying greatly by region. Changing climates, hunter-gatherer adaptation, landscape, mobility, animals, burial, memory, aggregation, and growing social complexity.

Settling the World (49)
The Neolithic Transformation
Beginning roughly 10,000 BCE in Southwest Asia, with different chronologies elsewhere. Agriculture, domestication, settlement, houses, ancestors, monumental gathering, fertility, land, ownership, social differentiation, and new relationships between humanity and environment.

When Villages Became Civilizations (50)
Cities, Temples, Kings, Priests, and Writing
The emergence of urban life, political hierarchy, organized religion, specialized labor, monumental architecture, record keeping, and writing. Human memory could now exist outside individual minds. Stories could survive their storytellers.

When Stories Became Literature (51)
Sumer, Akkad, Babylon, Egypt, and Canaan
Oral and ritual worlds increasingly became written worlds. Creation, kingship, gods, catastrophe, law, wisdom, suffering, mortality, sacred order, and cosmic meaning became preserved in texts.

From the Ancient Near East to Israel (52)
The Cultural World From Which Biblical Literature Emerged
Canaanite, Egyptian, Mesopotamian, Levantine, and Israelite worlds intersect. Israel inherits, participates in, contests, adapts, and transforms traditions within this larger environment.

A Very Long Genealogy of Genesis (53)
From Symbolic Humanity to Biblical Narrative
The synthesis of the chronological journey:
Paleolithic symbolic consciousness → animal / death / ancestor / landscape worlds → Mesolithic ritual and social worlds → Neolithic communal cosmologies → agricultural and settled societies → urban temple cosmologies → Sumerian literary traditions → Akkadian and Babylonian traditions → Canaanite / Egyptian / Near Eastern narrative worlds → Israelite interpretation → Torah / Prophets / Wisdom → Jewish and Christian interpretation.
This is not a claim that we can trace Genesis directly backward to Paleolithic humanity. We cannot. It is a history of increasingly elaborate human capacities for symbol, ritual, narrative, religion, social organization, and cultural memory. Biblical narrative may therefore be understood as one comparatively recent branch of humanity's enormously ancient practice of narrating reality.


Interlude III
The Turning Point

We began with Christians holding a Bible. We excavated backward until there was no Christianity. Then no Judaism. No Israel. No Bible. No writing. No city. No agriculture. Perhaps no identifiable religion. Only evolving human beings living together within an evolving world. Then we turned around and watched those human beings become symbolic, narrative, ritual, agricultural, urban, literary, and religious creatures. And eventually: there was a Bible which we might read again through the lens of prehistory.

The Architecture of Biblical Prehistory
Phase 3 - Returning to the Bible

We now turn back to the Bible to reread its pages having recovered its prehistory. Our final journey now asks: What does knowing all of this change within us, the people around us, and the societies around the world?

Movement IX - The Bible in the Evolving Story of Humanity
Inheritance, Transformation, and Biblical Contribution

Genesis Among the Ancients (54)
Creation Reconsidered
After encountering the cosmologies and creation traditions of the ancient world we return to Genesis. What does Genesis share with that world? What does it transform? What questions does it answer differently?

Adam, Eve, and Becoming Human (55)
Ancient Anthropology After Human Evolution
What happens to Adam and Eve when Genesis is no longer required to function as modern biological history? How does ancient anthropology, human identity, mortality, moral consciousness, sexuality, relationship, labor, land, and exile make humanity's legacy meaningful?

Eden, Cain, Noah, and Babel (56)
Mortality, Violence, Catastrophe, and Civilization
Reading the biblical primeval narratives within their ancient literary environments and within the vastly deeper human history now recovered.

Abraham, Exodus, and Israel's Remembered Past (57)
History, Tradition, Identity, and Meaning
Ancestral memory, migration, liberation, covenant, land, identity, and the relationship between remembered narrative and historical reconstruction.

Prophets, Wisdom, and the Human Condition (58)
Justice, Suffering, Meaning, and Hope
Prophetic justice, Psalms, Job, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, suffering, moral responsibility, political power, meaning, meaninglessness, and hope.

What Did Israel Do With the Ancient World? (59)
Inheritance, Rejection, Transformation, and Contribution
Moving beyond the simplistic proposition: Gilgamesh → Genesis where Israel seemingly "copied" pagan mythology. The richer questions concern shared cultural inheritance, adaptation, polemic, reinterpretation, innovation, memory, and the distinct contributions biblical writers made to humanity's older conversations.

Movement X - The Bible After the Bible
How Ancient Texts Created New Worlds

From Hebrew Bible to Jewish Scripture (60)
Interpretation Never Stopped
Examining the wider Jewish literary world of canonical and non-canonical writings, including the Apocrypha, Pseudepigrapha, Enochic traditions, and Dead Sea Scrolls. Exploring diverse understandings of God, religious experience, conscience, and human responsibility, and how continuing interpretation shaped scriptural authority.

From Jewish Scripture to Christian Bible (61)
Jesus, Christ, Paul, and a New Interpretive World
Tracing how early Christian communities reinterpreted Jewish Scriptures through their experiences and understandings of Jesus. Examining the canonical New Testament alongside non-canonical gospels, apostolic writings, apocalypses, and other Christian literature, revealing developing understandings of God, salvation, conscience, and scriptural authority.

new addition --->

The Historical Genealogy of Biblical and Christian Belief (62)
From Ancient Divine Worlds to Israel, Judaism, and Christianity

The religious ideas eventually associated with biblical faith and Christianity did not originate as a single, fully developed theological system. They emerged through a long history of human religious interpretation extending from the ancient Near Eastern civilizations through Israelite religion, Second Temple Judaism, the early Jesus movements, and the developing Christian churches.

This essay reconstructs that genealogy by tracing the inheritance, transformation, rejection, and recombination of major religious ideas: divine identity, creation, cosmic order, sacred kingship, covenant, sacrifice, prophecy, wisdom, mortality, resurrection, messianic expectation, divine mediation, and the developing status of Jesus as Messiah, Lord, Son of God, and divine Logos.

Rather than presenting Christianity as the inevitable culmination of earlier religious developments, it examines Christianity as a historically particular movement arising within Judaism and subsequently developing through interaction with wider Greco-Roman cultures. Judaism continues its own historical development, while Christianity inherits and reinterprets Jewish traditions through its understanding of Jesus.

The purpose is to distinguish historical ancestry from theological truth. Demonstrating how religious beliefs developed does not establish either the existence or nonexistence of the divine realities to which those beliefs refer. It does reveal that religious understanding has always been mediated through human language, cultural memory, historical experience, social institutions, and changing interpretations of reality.

The central question is therefore not simply where Christian beliefs originated, but how earlier religious understandings became reorganized into the distinctive theological claims of Judaism and Christianity, and what this historical genealogy means for interpreting those claims today.

I. Religion Has a History
Why religious concepts possess genealogies rather than timeless, unchanging forms

II. The Ancient Inheritance
Divine councils, cosmic order, sacred kingship, temples, sacrifice, and mortality

III. Israel's Transformations
YHWH, El traditions, covenant, prophecy, justice, and emerging monotheism

IV. Judaism's Continuing Development
Torah, wisdom, apocalypticism, resurrection, messianic expectation, angels, and divine mediation

V. Christianity's Reinterpretation
Jesus, Messiah, Lord, Son of God, resurrection, Logos, developing Christology

VI. Inheritance, Innovation, and Consolidation
How earlier religious concepts became reorganized within emerging Christian theology

Conclusion
Historical ancestry and the continuing question of divine reality

 Essay 61 must distinguish three kinds of genealogy:

Kind

Central question

Historical genealogy

When, where, and through which communities did particular religious ideas develop?

Conceptual genealogy

How did the meanings of inherited ideas change as they entered new relationships?

Theological interpretation

What, if anything, might these changing understandings disclose about divine reality?

The first two properly belong to Essay 61. The third may be introduced as an open question but should receive its fuller treatment in Essays 69–71, especially God After Deep Time and Jesus After Historical Understanding. That distinction will keep the new essay consistent with the method established at the beginning of the series.


When Interpretation Became Doctrine (63)
Scripture, Philosophy, Creed, and Christian Tradition
How philosophical, theological, institutional, and cultural worlds shaped later Christian understandings of Scripture. The question is no longer merely: What does the Bible say? But also: What have later communities taught us to think the Bible says?

The Modern Bible (64)
Science, History, Evolution, Fundamentalism, and Evangelicalism
Geology, evolutionary biology, archaeology, historical criticism, modernity, fundamentalism, evangelicalism, and the emergence of contemporary disputes about biblical authority and interpretation.

Movement XI - The Stories We Still Live By
Ancient Story and Modern Humanity

The Myth-Making Animal Never Disappeared (65)
Narrative After the Ancient World
Modern humanity did not cease constructing world-organizing narratives. Religious and secular societies alike continue to interpret themselves through stories of identity, origin, destiny, progress, nation, economy, technology, catastrophe, salvation, and hope.

Stories That Bind and Stories That Divide (66)
Cooperation, Belonging, Identity, and Power
Shared narratives can enable extraordinary cooperation. They can also establish boundaries between insider and outsider, neighbor and enemy, belonging and exclusion. The ancient storytelling creature remains morally ambiguous.

What Are Our Stories Doing to Us? (67)
Human Becoming in the Modern World
The ancient human capacity for narrative now operates within technological civilization, ecological crisis, global interdependence, mass communication, artificial intelligence, and unprecedented human power. Our stories still shape what kinds of humans we become whether good or bad.

Movement XII - What Do We Do with the Bible Now?
Faith After Historical Understanding

The Bible After Biblical Prehistory (68)
What Kind of Book Have We Inherited?
Returning to Scripture after restoring its evolutionary, archaeological, cultural, historical, religious, and literary background. The Bible becomes neither a magical book dropped outside history nor merely another ancient artifact. It becomes an extraordinary collection of ancient human religious voices arising from within humanity's long search for meaning.

Myth, History, and Truth (69)
Beyond the Choice Between Literalism and Rejection
What is myth? What is history? What is memory? What is theological narrative? Can ancient literature convey profound truth without functioning as modern science or historiography?

Revelation, Inspiration, and Inerrancy (70)
Questions That Return After History
These theological questions were deliberately bracketed at the beginning. Only after recovering the historical Bible do we return to them. What might revelation and inspiration mean after historical criticism? What becomes of inerrancy? What kind of Scripture remains possible?

God After Deep Time (71)
Does Historical Understanding Make God Disappear?
Evolution does not by itself answer the theological question of God. Neither does archaeology. Neither does comparative mythology. We return to God only after distinguishing historical description from theological interpretation. For some, God remains a question. For others, God remains wonder, mystery, and truth.

Jesus After Historical Understanding (72)
Following Jesus in a Historically Conscious Christianity
Returning to Jesus and Christ after recovering the deep histories of humanity, religion, Israel, Judaism, Scripture, and Christianity. What might following Jesus mean when Christian faith no longer requires a historically contextless Bible?

Movement XIII - How Then Shall We Live?
Human Becoming and the Expanding Possibility of Care

Human Beings Became Human Together (73)
Humanity's Long Moral Inheritance
We return to the deep evolutionary sociality encountered at the deepest levels of our study. Caring for offspring. The fidelity of kinship. Sharing of food and goods. Cooperation. Reciprocity. Community. Living through conflict and violence. Seeking protection and shelter. Enduring grief. And learning to belong with one another. Across this wide spectrum humanity feels the moral possibilities that emerge within the ancient tensions that exist between care and domination, cooperation and competition, hospitality and exclusion.

The Expanding Circle of Moral Belonging (74)
Kin, Stranger, Humanity, Earth
The moral circle can widen from self → family → kin → community → stranger → humanity → other creatures → Earth → future generations. And perhaps, someday, toward genuinely conscious beings humanity itself may create. But enlargement is never inevitable. Humanity repeatedly contracts the circle of care and love even as it struggles to enlarge it.

What Do We Do With Our Humanity? (75)
The Question Beneath the Biblical Question
After asking what we should do with the Bible, a deeper question remains. What shall we do with the extraordinary human capacities for memory, imagination, narrative, religion, cooperation, violence, creativity, compassion, and love that eventually produced it?

How Then Shall We Live? (76)
From Humanity's Ancient Questions to Our Own
Our languages have changed. Our cosmologies have changed. Our technologies have changed. Our civilizations have changed. Yet humanity continues to confront birth and death, suffering and joy, violence and peace, belonging and exclusion, wonder and mystery, stranger and neighbor, Earth and one another. The study therefore ends where humanity's ancient search repeatedly returns: How might we become more compassionate participants in the world we now inhabit? How shall we care for one another, for the stranger, for the suffering, for Earth and its wild things, and for those who will inhabit the world after us? And finally: How then shall we live?


Conclusion
How Then Shall We Live?

We have traveled backward from the Bible we inherited through Christianity, Judaism, ancient Israel, the civilizations of the ancient Near East, the prehistoric worlds of early humanity, and finally into the evolutionary history from which human beings emerged. We then turned around and followed humanity forward again - through sociality and care, communication and symbol, ritual and narrative, settlement and civilization, writing and religion - until we encountered the Bible once more. But having recovered its prehistory, we no longer encounter the Bible without a history. The Bible now has an address.

The Architecture of Biblical Prehistory

Phase 1 - The Excavation


Where did the Bible come from?

The Bible We Inherited → Christianity → Jesus and Second Temple Judaism → Ancient Israel and Judah → Canaan / Ugarit / Egypt / Mesopotamia → Neolithic and Mesolithic Humanity → Paleolithic Symbolic Worlds → Human Evolution


Phase 2 - The Long Human Journey


What happened across deep human time?

Human Evolution → Sociality and Care → Communication → Symbol → Ritual → Narrative → Myth → Settlement and Agriculture → Civilization → Writing → Ancient Cosmology and Religion → Israel → Biblical Literature

This is not a straight line of inevitable progress. It is a history of branching, inheritance, loss, innovation, adaptation, conflict, continuity, and becoming.


Phase 3 - The Return


What does knowing this change?

Biblical Narrative → Jewish Interpretation → Jesus and Christianity → Later Christian Interpretation → The Modern Bible → Historical Understanding → Our Own Narrative Worlds → Human Responsibility


Four Questions Govern the Study

The Historical Question

Where did the Bible come from?

The Human Question

How did evolutionary creatures become creatures capable of symbol, religion, story, and Scripture?

The Interpretive Question

What happens to the Bible when we return it to the immense human history from which it arose?

The Participatory Question

What shall we do with this inheritance now?


The Journey in One Movement

We begin with a Bible in our hands.

We excavate backward until the Bible disappears. We continue until civilization disappears, writing disappears, and agriculture disappears. Recognizable religion becomes increasingly difficult to identify. Eventually we encounter evolving human beings living together within an evolving world.

Then we turn around.

We watch humans care. We watch them communicate. We watch them remember. We watch them symbolize. We watch them bury their dead. We watch them paint. We watch them gather. We watch them settle. We watch them farm. We watch them build. We watch them tell stories. We watch stories become traditions. We watch traditions become civilizations. We watch civilizations write. We watch written stories become sacred stories.

And eventually we encounter the Bible again.

But now the Bible has an address.

And the question with which we began has become larger.

We began by asking:

Where did the Bible come from?

We end by asking:

What do we do with the humanity that created, inherited, preserved, interpreted, contested, loved, feared, and continues to live through its stories?

The Bible belongs within that immense human story. It did not introduce humanity to the great questions of existence. It inherited questions already ancient when its earliest traditions arose, gave them particular voices within the worlds of Israel and Judaism, and passed those voices onward into Christianity and beyond. To recover that history need not make the Bible smaller. It may instead make both the Bible and humanity's story considerably larger.

And perhaps that is where biblical prehistory finally returns us - not merely to questions about what ancient people believed, nor even to questions about what we should believe about their writings, but to the human beings who created, inherited, preserved, interpreted, and continually reinterpreted them. Their questions have become our questions because we belong to the same unfinished human story.

We still confront birth and death, love and loss, suffering and joy, violence and peace, belonging and exclusion, stranger and neighbor, Earth and one another. We still construct stories by which we understand ourselves and our world. And we still must decide what kinds of people those stories will help us become.

And beneath all these questions remains humanity's ancient question:

How then shall we live?


R.E. Slater and ChatGPT
September 2026



Index - Relation Between Christianity & Philosophy



Index - Relation Between
Christianity & Philosophy

The Philosophical Worlds That Shaped Christian Belief -
and the Christianity That Continues to Reimagine Its Worlds of Belief

by R.E. Slater & ChatGPT


Christianity did not enter a world without philosophy.
It entered worlds already filled with understandings of
reality, humanity, divinity, life, death, and what might lie beyond them.

Every generation inherits a Christianity already interpreted -
which it interprets again within the world it has inherited.

The question is not whether Christianity will inhabit
a philosophical and cultural world,
but whether it will recognize the worlds it inhabits
and take responsibility for the Christianity
which continues to become.

- R.E. Slater & ChatGPT




~ This project is not completed but is provided as a future series of essays
to follow the completion of the Reality & Metaphysics series currently underway
and possibly The Prehistory of the Bible and/or The Development of Early
Christianity series yet to be written ~


Path 1 - Historical Genealogy

How did changing philosophical worlds change Christianity?

Prehistoric meaning-making → Ancient civilizations → Ancient Near East → Israel → Second Temple Judaism → Greek/Hellenistic worlds → Early Christianity → Church Fathers → Augustine → Medieval Christianity → Aquinas → Renaissance/Reformation → Descartes → Enlightenment → Modernity → Contemporary Christianity


Path 2 - The Genealogy of Christian Beliefs

Where did the things Christians believe actually come from?

Instead of organizing primarily around eras, we could organize around major Christian ideas:

God - Creation - Human Nature - Body and Soul - Sin - Christ - Spirit - Revelation - Scripture - Providence - Freedom - Salvation - Death - Heaven - Resurrection - Eternity - Eschatology

For each concept we could trace something like:

ancient antecedents → Hebrew/Jewish forms → New Testament forms → Greek philosophical encounter → patristic development → medieval synthesis → Reformation transformation → modern reconstruction → contemporary Christianity 

 


Path 3 - Christianity's Changing Metaphysics

What did Christians in each period assume reality was like - and how did that assumption shape what Christianity became?

This is closer to what today's R&M discussion uncovered.

Rather than tracing Christianity generally, we trace the successive pictures of reality through which Christianity interpreted itself:

Ancient cosmological worlds → Hebrew relational/embodied worlds → Greek metaphysics → Platonic Christianity → Aristotelian Christianity → Scholastic synthesis → Cartesian reality → Enlightenment reality → scientific/evolutionary reality → modern naturalism/supernaturalism → process and relational reality

 


Path 4 - Christianity's Great Philosophical Problems

What philosophical problems has Christianity been trying to solve - sometimes without recognizing them as philosophical problems?

Instead of eras or doctrines, organize around enduring problems:

Being and Becoming
One and Many
Body and Soul
Mind and Matter
Time and Eternity
Freedom and Determinism
Good and Evil
Knowledge and Revelation
Reason and Faith
Nature and Supernature
Identity and Resurrection
History and Eschatology
God and World

Each problem could travel through the entire history of Christianity.



Path 5 - How Philosophy Changed Christianity
& Christianity Changed Philosophy

Instead of portraying Christianity as the passive recipient of Greek philosophy, we would follow two-way transformations.

Platonism helped Christians articulate transcendence, soul, God, and eternity - but Christianity also transformed Platonism through creation, incarnation, resurrection, history, and personal divine agency.

Aristotle transformed medieval Christian thought - but medieval Christian thinkers also reconstructed Aristotle.

Modern philosophy destabilized traditional Christian epistemology - while Christian theological problems helped shape modern discussions of personhood, freedom, morality, history, and meaning.

The series becomes a history of reciprocal intellectual becoming.

This is attractive because it avoids the simplistic thesis that philosophy somehow "corrupted" an originally pure Christianity.



Path 6 - The Philosophical Worlds That Made Christianity Possible

The Philosophical Worlds That Made Christianity Possible: Antecedents of belief before Christianity, before Israel, and before philosophy had a name.

The progression might be:

Experience → symbolic interpretation → myth → cosmology → theology → explicit philosophical reflection → systematic philosophy

We investigate ancient human meaning-making, Mesopotamia, Egypt, Canaan, Israel, wisdom traditions, apocalypticism, Second Temple Judaism, Hellenism, and only eventually Christianity.

This route would strongly connect with the future Prehistory of the Bible project, perhaps too strongly. Its danger is that Christianity might not appear until quite far into a series called Christianity and Philosophy.


Path 7 - Philosophical Archaeology of Christianity

Here we conduct an archaeology of belief as to why contemporary Christianity holds so much eclectic behaviour and beliefs within its global church body thus necessitating our relational philosophy project that suggests recentering the Christian faith upon a holistic foundation.

We begin with Christianity as it exists now, particularly the strange mixture we noticed in contemporary evangelical and popular Christianity, and ask:

How did all of this get here?

Take contemporary assumptions and excavate their layers.

A Christian today might simultaneously believe in:

biblical creation + Greek soul + Augustinian God + medieval heaven + Reformation salvation + Cartesian mind/body + Enlightenment certainty + modern supernaturalism + nineteenth-century revivalism + twentieth-century fundamentalism.

As such, the accumulating layers of philosophical egress are peeled away one by one:

Contemporary Christianity
↓
Modernity and Fundamentalism
↓
Enlightenment
↓
Reformation
↓
Medieval Christianity
↓
Augustine and the Fathers
↓
Hellenistic Christianity
↓
Second Temple Judaism
↓
Ancient Israel
↓
Ancient Near Eastern worlds

And then perhaps travel forward again, now understanding how the pieces accumulated which could make historical sedimentation the organizing metaphor of the entire project.



Path 8 - Developing a Hybrid Architecture

The history portion could become the spine, the philosophical problems the cross-sections, and genealogy become the method.

So we move broadly chronologically, but within every historical period ask the same recurring questions:

What is real?
What is God?
What is a human being?
What happens at death?
How can God act?
What can humans know?
What is time?
What is salvation?
What is the future?

And underneath the whole inquiry we retain our methodological sequence:

Experience → Language → Interpretation → Metaphysical Construction

followed recursively by:

Metaphysical Construction → Theology → Practice → New Experience

This would allow us to watch not only which ideas Christianity acquired, but how an interpretation eventually became a doctrine, how a doctrine became a worldview, and how a worldview subsequently shaped Christian experience itself.



FULL PROJECT SUGGESTION

Experience → Language → Interpretation → Metaphysical Construction → Theological Construction → Religious Practice → New Experience

Of note, there is an overlap of layers but each layer is not identical to the other:

Historical genealogy ≠ philosophical genealogy ≠ theological genealogy


Possibly consider using each path as its own essay(s) to create a fuller series that can suggest multiple approaches and realizations the the subject matter itself... this then would create a more complete essay series rather than forcing its into one organizing principle. Christianity itself did not develop along a single intellectual trajectory, so a series examining its relationship with philosophy arguably should not pretend that one historical lens can disclose everything.

Instead, the paths that are identified above could become movements within the series, each revisiting Christianity from a different angle. The apparent repetition would not necessarily be redundancy - provided each return asks a genuinely different question. Hence, we might have an emergent architecture something like this:

Christianity and Philosophy

How Philosophy Changed Christianity - and Christianity Changed Philosophy
The Philosophical Worlds That Made Christianity Possible

Movement I - Before Christianity: Philosophy Before Philosophy Had a Name
This develops Path 6. Human experience, symbolic thought, myth, ancient cosmologies, Ancient Near Eastern worlds, Hebrew thought, Second Temple Judaism, and Hellenism. Its purpose is to establish our foundational proposition: no human religious world is philosophically innocent simply because it lacks a formal discipline called philosophy.

Movement II - A Historical Genealogy of Christianity and Philosophy
Path 1 becomes the principal historical narrative. We follow Christianity through its encounters with Hellenism, patristic thought, Augustine, Aristotle and scholasticism, Renaissance and Reformation, Descartes, Enlightenment, science, modernity, and contemporary philosophy. This answers: What happened, when, and why?

Movement III - The Philosophical Worlds Christianity Inherited
Path 3. Now we revisit that history metaphysically rather than merely chronologically. What pictures of reality were operating beneath Christian theology? Substance, participation, hierarchy, being, eternity, dualism, mechanism, natural/supernatural distinctions, historical becoming, evolution, process, relation. The question becomes: What did Christians assume reality was like?

Movement IV - The Genealogy of Christian Beliefs
Path 2. Instead of periods, we follow doctrines across periods: God, creation, human nature, body/soul, sin, incarnation, revelation, providence, salvation, death, heaven, resurrection, eternity, eschatology. This asks the wonderfully uncomfortable question: Where did the things Christians came to believe actually come from?

Movement V - Christianity's Great Philosophical Problems
Path 4. Now we abstract still further from particular doctrines and examine the persistent problems underneath them: being/becoming, one/many, body/soul, mind/matter, time/eternity, freedom/determinism, good/evil, reason/revelation, nature/supernature, identity/resurrection, history/eschatology, God/world. Here Christianity becomes a participant in philosophy's enduring questions.

Movement VI - Philosophy Changed Christianity - Christianity Changed Philosophy
Path 5. This is important because it corrects any impression created by the previous movements that Christianity merely received philosophy. Christianity also altered the philosophical worlds it entered. Creation, incarnation, resurrection, personhood, history, contingency, freedom, morality, and eschatological futurity all put pressure upon inherited philosophical categories. This becomes the explicitly reciprocal movement.

Movement VII - The Philosophical Archaeology of Christianity
Path 7. Only after we know the history do we return to contemporary Christianity and excavate it. We could take recognizable contemporary beliefs and ask which historical strata remain embedded within them. This could be especially illuminating for evangelical Christianity without making evangelicalism the sole target of the series. Catholic, Orthodox, mainline Protestant, Pentecostal, liberal, evangelical, and other Christian traditions will preserve different combinations of the sediment.

We then include the eighth movement that wasn't quite contained in our original seven paths.

Movement VIII - Christianity After Its Philosophical Archaeology
How does Christianity responsibly participate in a world containing many philosophies, sciences, cultures, religions, and ways of interpreting reality?
Path 8 - Christianity Turns Around and Looks at Itself. Having traced the philosophical worlds Christianity inherited, transformed, resisted, absorbed, and eventually came to experience as part of Christianity itself, the inquiry finally turns reflexively toward Christianity in the present. If Christianity has always interpreted its inherited traditions through changing understandings of reality, what follows from recognizing that history?

The answer cannot simply be:

Greek philosophy corrupted Christianity, so remove it.

Nor:

Classical metaphysics was Christianity's final philosophical achievement, so preserve it unchanged.

Nor even:

Relational metaphysics is correct, so replace everything with GRR.

Each response would repeat the very problem the historical inquiry has uncovered: treating one historically situated interpretation of reality as though it stood outside history and interpretation altogether.

Instead, the concluding question becomes:

If Christianity has continually interpreted its traditions through changing understandings of reality, how should it responsibly engage not only philosophy, but the varieties of pluralistic human culture now?

This widens the conversation considerably. Contemporary Christianity encounters not one philosophical world but many: naturalism, phenomenology, existentialism, process philosophy, relational philosophy, philosophy of mind, scientific realism, evolutionary biology and cosmology, historical criticism, psychology, anthropology, religious pluralism, secular humanism, and the diverse philosophical and religious traditions of a globally interconnected humanity. Christianity's contemporary interpretive environment is therefore no less historically conditioned than those through which it previously developed.

The question is consequently not whether Christianity can somehow escape philosophy, culture, history, or interpretation. Its history suggests that it never has. The more responsible question is how Christianity might become increasingly conscious of the interpretive worlds through which it understands itself, distinguishing inherited tradition from subsequent philosophical construction while remaining willing to reconsider both in continuing conversation with reality and human experience.

Generative Relational Realism may enter this final conversation, along with process and relational philosophies, but not as the predetermined winner of the historical investigation. GRR itself is another historically situated philosophical proposal and must remain subject to the same disciplines of criticism, evidence, comparison, and revision applied throughout the series. A relational theology cannot claim to have finally escaped metaphysics; it can only become more explicit about the metaphysical commitments through which it interprets Christian traditions.

Movement VIII therefore does not conclude by identifying the philosophy Christianity should adopt. It arrives instead at a posture of continuing philosophical and cultural engagement: historically conscious, interpretively self-aware, pluralistically conversant, critically discerning, and open to revision.

The series can therefore end where its investigation ultimately leads:

Christianity has never existed apart from interpretation. Its future responsibility may be not to escape the philosophical and cultural worlds in which it lives, but to become more conscious of them - and more responsible for the Christianity it continues to become.

 

Thursday, September 17, 2026

Index - Time & Temporal Becoming



Index - Time & Temporal Becoming

Essays on Time, Temporality, Cosmology, & Becoming

by R.E. Slater

Section I - Chronological Index
Section II - Topical and Conceptual Index
Section III - R&M Series: The Temporal Structure of Becoming


Reflections on Time and Becoming

Reality does not merely exist in time.
It inherits a past, becomes a present,
and opens toward possibilities
that have not yet become.

- R.E. Slater

Time may not be the stage upon which reality acts.
It may be one of the ways reality leaves a history
as relation becomes event,
and possibility becomes actuality.

- R.E. Slater



Introduction - From Cosmic Time to Relational Becoming

The essays collected in this index span nearly two decades of inquiry into time, cosmology, process, and becoming. They began largely through questions raised by Stephen Hawking, quantum cosmology, the Big Bang, indeterminacy, multiverses, and the possible origin of time. They subsequently moved through entropy and temporal direction, primordial time, Einstein and Bergson, Whitehead and process philosophy, and eventually toward relational and generative accounts of reality.

Its resulting intellectual genealogy may be expressed simply:

Cosmic Time → Quantum Possibility → Primordial Time → Entropy and Irreversibility → Processual Time → Relational Time → Temporality and Becoming → Generative Relational Reality

The older essays should not be understood as already containing the conclusions of Generative Relational Realism which was recently derived in the Reality & Metaphysics series. Some of the essays reflect scientific, philosophical, and theological assumptions belonging to the periods in which they were written and will require reconsideration in light of the progress of contemporary scholarship.

Nevertheless, their continuing importance lies elsewhere. They preserve the questions through which original inquiries developed and have transitioned over time to this present moment. Questions such as:

Did time have a beginning?

What does “before” mean if spacetime itself has an origin?

Why does time possess a direction?

Is the future determined, merely unknown, or genuinely unrealized?

How does possibility become actuality?

How can anything persist while continually changing?

Does becoming occur within time, or does becoming participate in constituting temporality?

How does temporal reality eventually become remembered, anticipated, interpreted, and consciously lived?

These questions will now become the subject of sustained examination in Reality & Metaphysics, Section IX - "The Temporal Structure of Becoming." Here, we'll examine the sequence:

How Time brought us to becoming →

How Becoming brought us to relation →

How Relation returns us to time →

So that the question remains open:

What kind of reality must there be if reality is never finished becoming?



Chronological Index
Hawking and Cosmic Time → Quantum Possibility → Origin of Time → Arrow and Entropy → Processual Time → Relational Time → Temporality and Becoming → GRR
~ Please refer to the Topical and Conceptual Index further below where the essays
in this historical section are sorted and organized by topic and concept ~


2012 - Hawking, Quantum Cosmology, and Possibility

April 26 - Stephen Hawking, The Grand Design of God and the Cosmos

Cosmic origins, natural law, creation, determinism, Hawking, and The Grand Design. This essay begins a sustained engagement with Hawking's cosmology and its implications for theology, indeterminacy, and the character of the universe.

May 24 - Stephen Hawking, Multi-Universes, and God's Grander Design

Multiverse cosmology, cosmic possibility, alternative universes, and the theological implications of a universe containing multiple possible histories.

May 30 - Stephen Hawking, Indeterminacy, God & Quantum Physics

Quantum indeterminacy, determinism, possibility, divine action, and the openness of physical reality.

June 27 - Stephen Hawking: The Strangeness of Quantum Physics and Cosmic Indeterminacy

Alternative histories, probability, quantum cosmology, multiverses, and cosmic openness. The June essay explicitly identifies itself as a continuation of the preceding engagement with Hawking's The Grand Design and lists the earlier Hawking essays. The four articles therefore constitute a recognizable Hawking sequence within Relevancy22.

Historical movement:

cosmic origins → multiverse → indeterminacy → alternative histories → cosmic possibility


2013 - Time Becomes a Metaphysical Problem

The earlier cosmological questions now begin turning explicitly toward the nature and origin of time itself.

Where Does Space and Time Come From?

God and Time: The (Quantum) Physics of Time (background)

What Is Time? And How Does It Relate to God?

God and Time: God is Not Eternal

God and Time: The Mystery of the Incarnate God Eternal (research/background)

These essays and research materials are preserved together in the Relevancy22 Process Sciences index:

February 12 - The Paradox of Quantum SpaceTime for Emergent Theology Today

An early sustained attempt to consider time in relation to origin, causality, connection, necessity, quantum theory, and the possibility that ordinary spacetime may not be metaphysically fundamental.

November - The Science Behind “Creatio Continua” versus “Creatio Ex Nihilo” (Process v. Classical Thought)

An important additional precursor. Although primarily concerned with creation, process, and cosmology, the essay contains an early attempt to think about primordial reality, the emergence of ordinary temporal structure, and a universe understood dynamically rather than as a completed creation.

Historical movement:

cosmology → origin of time → nature of time → primordial temporality → theological temporality


2017 - Hawking and Quantum Cosmology Revisited

March 8 - R.E. Slater - The Quantum Universe We Live In

A return to Hawking and quantum cosmology in light of subsequent scientific discussion, including the scale and structure of the universe, inflation, cosmic origins, and the limits of ordinary spatial and temporal language.


2020 - Irreversibility and the Arrow of Time

Questions of Time: Is the Source to Time's Arrow Based on Entropy or Gravitation?

A research-oriented investigation of the physical source of temporal directionality.

June 15 - Science / Philosophy - Why Time Travel IS NOT Possible

A significant original essay connecting the physical arrow of time with process philosophy. The argument begins moving beyond time as measurement toward time as irreversible becoming within an unfinished reality.

Does God Live Outside of Time? Can There Be Such a Concept? (research/background)

June 22 - Can God Live Outside of Time? Why Would This NOT Be Important?

A sustained theological and philosophical treatment of primordial time, divine temporality, process, and the possibility that time belongs intrinsically to becoming rather than functioning merely as an external container.

What Happened Before the Big Bang?

A return to primordial cosmology, including the Hawking/no-boundary question and whether “before” remains meaningful if ordinary spacetime itself has an origin.

These essays mark a decisive movement toward:

irreversibility → temporal direction → primordial time → open futurity → processual becoming


2021 - Entropy and Temporal Direction

May 18 - Time is an Entropic System - To Go Back In Time is to Reverse the Second Law of Thermodynamics

A physical treatment of clocks, entropy, the second law of thermodynamics, and temporal directionality.

This material becomes important background for the future R&M essay The Arrow of Time and the Direction of Becoming.


2022 - Processual and Primordial Time

January 24 - COSMOLOGY - What Is Processual Primordial Time before the Big Bang?

A major development in the genealogy. Time is now being investigated explicitly through process philosophy and primordial cosmology, including the possibility that ordinary spacetime is not the most fundamental temporal reality.

February 15 - Time & the Primordial Universe - Einstein vs. Bergson, by Campo & Gozzano

An unusually rich research collection spanning Einstein, Bergson, Rovelli, Whitehead, processuality, human and cosmic time, metaphysics, neuroscience, biology, and cosmology.

February - COSMOLOGY - The Philosophy of MetaPhysical Cosmology

A broader philosophical examination of cosmology and its unavoidable metaphysical questions, including the nature of time and the relationship between physics and philosophy.

February 23 - How Process Philosophy & Theology Connects Scientific Evolution & Cosmology to God

Connects process cosmology, evolutionary reality, temporality, and theology while explicitly referring readers back to the primordial-time essay.

Historical movement:

physical time → primordial time → Bergsonian duration → Whiteheadian process → philosophical temporality


2025 - Relational Time

December 27 - Processual Becoming Across Relational Worlds: Relationality across Quantum Physics and a Becoming Cosmos

Relational Time and Emergent Geometry: From Quantum Information to Process Ontology

A major bridge into the present Reality & Metaphysics project. The essay brings quantum physics, relational physics, Whitehead, Bergson, Husserl, Merleau-Ponty, spacetime, causal order, and process ontology into a common conversation.

Its central intuition marks an important development:

Time is not the stage on which reality acts.

Time is the trace reality leaves as it becomes.

★ MAJOR PRECURSOR TO R&M SECTION IX


2026 - Temporality Becomes Explicitly Ontological

January 24 - What Is Reality? Theories and Their Limits (5)

Contains the major discussion “Temporality and Becoming,” asking whether time is illusion, coordinate, emergent structure, or constitutive feature of reality itself.

January - Why Process Is Metaphysically Necessary (6)

Moves the inquiry from comparison toward ontology. Temporality becomes part of the argument that reality possesses genuine history: events occur, consequences accumulate, possibilities are foreclosed, and what becomes conditions what may become next.

August 20 - Relational Freedom and Agency (29)

Develops the relationship among inherited conditions, constraint, openness, responsiveness, alternative possibility, agency, and becoming otherwise. The temporal question has now become inseparable from futurity:

Can reality genuinely become otherwise?


An especially important immediate precursor to the dedicated Time section. The essay explicitly asks whether process requires time or whether ordered succession within process might itself help constitute what we mean by time. Rather than prematurely answering the question, the essay deliberately postpones it for sustained examination in the future R&M section devoted to temporality.




Topical and Conceptual Index


A. What Is Time?

Where Does Space and Time Come From?

God and Time: The (Quantum) Physics of Time

What Is Time? And How Does It Relate to God?

The Paradox of Quantum SpaceTime for Emergent Theology Today

What Is Reality? Theories and Their Limits (5)

Why Process Is Metaphysically Necessary (6)

Future R&M: Time and Becoming


B. Cosmic Origins and the Emergence of Time

Stephen Hawking, The Grand Design of God and the Cosmos

What Happened Before the Big Bang?

COSMOLOGY - What Is Processual Primordial Time before the Big Bang?

The Quantum Universe We Live In

The Paradox of Quantum SpaceTime for Emergent Theology Today

The Science Behind “Creatio Continua” versus “Creatio Ex Nihilo”

Future R&M: The Origin and Emergence of Time


C. Competing Conceptions of Time

Time & the Primordial Universe - Einstein vs. Bergson, by Campo & Gozzano

Processual Becoming Across Relational Worlds

These collections introduce or engage Bergson, Einstein, Whitehead, Rovelli, process philosophy, relational physics, phenomenology, and competing conceptions of physical and experienced time.

Future R&M: Relational Time Among the Alternatives


D. Entropy, Irreversibility, and the Arrow of Time

Questions of Time: Is the Source to Time's Arrow Based on Entropy or Gravitation?

Science / Philosophy - Why Time Travel IS NOT Possible

Time is an Entropic System - To Go Back In Time is to Reverse the Second Law of Thermodynamics

Relevant portions of Why Process Is Metaphysically Necessary

Future R&M: The Arrow of Time and the Direction of Becoming


E. Persistence, History, and Identity

Why Process Is Metaphysically Necessary

What If Process Comes Before Relation?

Processual Becoming Across Relational Worlds

These writings increasingly treat persistence not as immunity from change but as continuity achieved through change. They also introduce the important question of temporal scale: what appears as an event at one scale may constitute a process at another.

Future R&M: Memory, Persistence, and Identity


F. Quantum Possibility, Novelty, and Futurity

Stephen Hawking, Multi-Universes, and God's Grander Design

Stephen Hawking, Indeterminacy, God & Quantum Physics

Stephen Hawking: The Strangeness of Quantum Physics and Cosmic Indeterminacy

The Quantum Universe We Live In

These early writings raise a question that later becomes central to GRR: whether possibility belongs merely to what observers do not yet know or whether reality itself possesses genuinely unrealized possibilities.

Future R&M: Novelty, Possibility, and Futurity


G. Freedom and Agency

Stephen Hawking, Indeterminacy, God & Quantum Physics

Relational Freedom and Agency (29)

Relevant GRR essays on generative agency and responsible participation. The mature question is no longer simply whether reality contains indeterminacy. It becomes:

How does openness become responsiveness, and how does sufficiently organized responsiveness become agency?

Future R&M: Freedom and Participatory Agency


H. Possibility and the Open Future

The 2012 Hawking indeterminacy sequence:

Science / Philosophy - Why Time Travel IS NOT Possible

Why Process Is Metaphysically Necessary

Relational Freedom and Agency

The developing question is whether the future is merely unknown or whether it is genuinely not-yet-actual.

Future R&M: Possibility, Hope, and an Open Future


I. Consciousness and Experienced Time

Time & the Primordial Universe - Einstein vs. Bergson

Processual Becoming Across Relational Worlds

The 2022 collection already opens the discussion toward human and cosmic time, neuroscience, biology, Bergsonian duration, and Whiteheadian process, while the later relational work expands the conversation toward phenomenology and embodied experience.

This category establishes an important distinction for future inquiry:

physical temporality ≠ ontological temporality ≠ experienced temporality

Future R&M: Consciousness and Temporality


J. God, Eternity, and Divine Temporality

God and Time: The (Quantum) Physics of Time

What Is Time? And How Does It Relate to God?

God and Time: God is Not Eternal

God and Time: The Mystery of the Incarnate God Eternal

Does God Live Outside of Time? Can There Be Such a Concept?

Can God Live Outside of Time? Why Would This NOT Be Important?

These writings preserve an important part of the intellectual genealogy. Before temporality became a sustained metaphysical problem within Reality & Metaphysics, it had already emerged through theological questions concerning eternity, divine action, creation, primordial reality, and whether God should be conceived as outside time or participating within an intrinsically temporal reality.

This material need not require a separate essay in R&M Section IX. It can remain an important historical archive and later provide source material for the development of Relational Theology.




Reality & Metaphysics Series
The Temporal Structure of Becoming


I. The Temporal Structure of Becoming

What Is Relational Time? - What is time within a reality that becomes; and does becoming occur in time, constitute temporality, generate temporality, or disclose some more complex relationship between time and relational becoming?

TIME AS A PROBLEM

Time and Becoming (XX)
Metaphysics XX - What Is Time in a Reality That Becomes?

Physical Time (XX)
Metaphysics XX - What Does Physics Actually Tell Us About Time?

Time, Simultaneity, and Relational Order (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Can Reality Possess Temporal Order Without a Universal Present?
Notes - This essay would build upon our discussion of Tim Maudlin and the relationship between philosophical time and Einsteinian relativity. It would investigate the distinction between universal time, local time, physical simultaneity, and the possibility of temporal ordering without a single cosmic present. Its importance for GRR is considerable. We must determine whether relational becoming requires a universal temporal structure or whether becoming can occur through locally ordered, physically related events without an absolute cosmic clock. This question is not adequately isolated in the present outline. It deserves its own essay because the relationship between relational becoming and relativity is one of the most consequential scientific challenges our philosophy must address.

Did Time Begin? (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Origin, Emergence, and the Limits of Temporal Language

TIME AS A METAPHYSICAL QUESTION

Time Among the Alternatives (XX)
Metaphysics XX - What Kind of Reality, If Any, Is Time?

Does Time Flow? (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Passage, Change, and the Problem of the Present

The Arrow of Time and the Direction of Becoming (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Why Is Reality Consequential and Apparently Irreversible?

TIME AS A CONSEQUENTIAL RELATIONAL REALITY

Does Becoming Require Time? (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Is Temporality Fundamental to Becoming, or Consequential Upon It?
This essay would directly examine a question we have returned to throughout our conversations: Does reality become because time exists, or does time emerge because reality becomes? More importantly, are these the only alternatives? Here we would explore four possibilities: temporality precedes becoming; becoming generates temporality; the two are mutually constitutive; or both emerge from a deeper relational organization. This essay would be especially important because GRR proposes the ontological priority of relation without automatically establishing that time, change, and becoming are identical. Its purpose would be critical investigation, not premature confirmation of our philosophy. One qualification: your mathematics section already contains Does Becoming Require Time? I would retain that mathematical essay, but distinguish it explicitly from this earlier ontological inquiry. The first asks what becoming requires metaphysically; the later essay asks what mathematical descriptions of transformation require temporally.

Time as Consequential Relational Reality (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Is Temporality an Achievement of Relational Becoming?

The Consequential Past (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Inheritance, Persistence, Memory, and Identity Across Becoming

Novelty, Possibility, and Futurity (XX)
Metaphysics XX - What Is the Ontological Status of the Not-Yet?

Freedom, Agency, and the Open Future (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Can Participants Make a Difference to What Becomes?

Consciousness and Manifest Time (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Memory, Anticipation, Presentness, and the Experience of Passage

TIME AS A LIVED REALITY

Interpreting from Within Becoming (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Understanding Reality Without Standing Outside Time

Living in Time (XX)
Metaphysics XX - Finitude, Meaning, and Participation Within Becoming

👉 These essays investigate time from physical, philosophical, relational, and lived perspectives. They ask whether time is fundamental or consequential; whether it flows, begins, or possesses direction; how the past persists and the future remains open; and how temporality becomes experienced, interpreted, and lived. Together they explore whether time contains becoming - or whether temporality itself may be a consequential reality generated through relational becoming.