Healing the Earth and One Another

Healing the Earth and One Another

by R.E. Slater

I've been utilizing Whiteheadian process philosophy for the last several years to develop both a theology of God and a theology of nature. One might be deemed a "supernatural theology" and the other a "natural theology." The former might also be described as a Process-based theology of faith and religion (in my case, Christianity) and the latter might be describes as a Process-based theology of all facets of creation. This latter theology is where I would like to start today....

When developing a natural theology, it is important to examine several items:

I. Is the philosophical foundation current, credible, and contemporary?

• My answer here is yes, when embracing Whitehead's organic process philosophy as a metaphysic, a cosmology, an ontology, an epistemology, and as an ethic. These have been discussed in their parts and their whole over the years on this site.

• And no, if embracing non-relational, non-experiential, and non-panpsychic philosophers which are inorganic, isolating, objectifiers of the world constructs, reductionistic, mechanistic, and inarticulate when conversing with metamodernism's sciences, disciplines, literatures, and philosophies.

• Process philosophy is an Integral and Integrating philosophy by which is meant that all previous philosophies are but elemental constructs of the whole and unworthy to expand or relativize such as all forms of Platonism, Scholasticism, Enlightenment philosophies, and etc.

Which is why it seems the most helpful, the most pertinent, and the most reasonable to state unequivocally that Whiteheadian organic process philosophy is the most current, credible, and contemporary of all the metaphysical philosophies at this date.

Whiteheadian Process Philosophy is also in its nascent phase meaning that many antecedent metaphysical constructs such as Alain Badiou's "Being and Event," Lucan, Deleuze, even Zizek, may be folded into Whiteheadian thought to help expand its reach and deepen it's perspectives in ways most helpful to metamodern societal directions in the arts, sciences, ecological economies, religion, and all other academias and disciplines.

II. Can the relational convection be affecting & integrating?

Another fundament element is a metaphysics currency with how the cosmos (sic, the universe) works in all its parts. From the quantum realms to the more visible realms of earth, water, air, fire, and spirit (this last, for me, refers to that panpsychic quality of a living, dynamic cosmogeny; and secondly, where a credible supernatural theology may be developed).

People like Charles Hartshorne, David Ray Griffin, and John Cobb, among others, took Whiteheadian thought and explored what it could mean for the natural sciences and theologies. It's latest iteration of concentrated effort is that of developing the mindset of building ecological civilizations resting upon processual ideations, the sciences, socio-political economies of scale, and the variable adaptations of these ideas across all spectrums of societal beliefs and organization.

"Saving the Planet" is an exemplary form of building ecological societies but without the necessary component of addressing relational cooperation, coordination, communication; or recognizing how all living biotic systems work in causal relational tandem with one another; then the mere objective to restore the earth will not work.

• Process-based ecological restoration means doing two things very well.... That is, we must learn to both "save the planet" and to "heal fractured societies."

• Processual reconciliation, redemptive activities, and repentant attitudes to the inequalities humanity has allowed to persist are part of the regenerative ethics of building ecological civilizations.

• Civilizations which are moving towards benevolence, equality, and the redress of man living in a dynamic, and organic, relational to creation and each other.

• No other philosophical metaphysic can work so well as the present one in healing both land, water, air and hearts.

Peace,

R.E. Slater

March 3, 2023

Series Posts

INDEX

Index - Evolution of Man & Religion

PART I

Bible Civilizations Are a Lot Younger Than Paleo-Human Civilizations

PART II

Climate change since the advent of humans

PART III

In the Days Before Genesis - Part 1, by R.E. Slater

PART IV

In the Days Before Genesis - Part 2, by R.E. Slater

ECO-CIV 1

Healing the Earth and One Another

ECO-CIV 2

Writing A Theology (of Love) for a Nuclear Age (of Brokenness)

* * * * * * * *

PROCESSUAL ECO-CIV REFERENCES

An Internet List of Process-based Studies & Titles

beyond the titles shown below

* * * * * *

ADDITIONAL REFERENCE TITLES SPEAKING TO

PROCESSUAL CIVILIZATIONS PAST & PRESENT

[Here are illustrations of creational thinking observing process-in-action

without knowing anything about Whiteheadian metaphysics]

10 Inspirational Guides to Healing the Planet

By Kinari Webb | 

Nov 16, 2021

Physician Kinari Webb’s valiant debut, Guardians of the Trees, addresses the links between climate change and health care head-on. She recalls the trip she made as a college student to Borneo, where she was struck by the intense need for medical care in the country’s remote villages. Not long after graduating from Yale’s medical school, Webb returned to Borneo, in hopes of helping mitigate the costly health care that led many to turn to illegal logging. Working with international and local teams, she eventually founded two nonprofits “designed to improve people’s health as the key to saving [the] rain forest.” After a near-fatal sting by a box jellyfish in July 2011, Webb was forced to scale back her hands-on humanitarian efforts, but her devotion to fighting for the health of the world and its people remains unflagging, as evidenced in her galvanizing and hopeful story.

Humanity is just beginning to awaken a series of interconnected crises that threaten our very survival as a species. These are the destabilization of our climate, the loss of much of the biodiversity on our planet, and colonialism and racism. What’s remarkable, though, is that by addressing these issues simultaneously, profound impacts can be achieved—hopefully enough to bring about a thriving future for all living beings.

Working alongside rainforest communities to improve their well-being and reverse the loss of rainforest has taught me that I can no more separate my own health from the health of the planet, than I can separate my own well-being from that of another human being’s. This was so vividly made clear to me in the first year I spent in Borneo, when I learned that people were often forced to cut down giant rainforest trees to access health care. In order to secure short-term survival, they were destroying an ecosystem they loved and saw as essential for their own and the planet’s long-term health.

At this critical juncture for humanity, I believe these 10 books can help us to believe change is possible, and to re-learn the critical importance of interconnection that most Indigenous and traditional communities have not forgotten. But this work of healing on a personal, community, and global level is not just intellectual, it is somatic, spiritual, and emotional I’ve found these books helpful in those realms, too.

1. Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants by Robin Wall Kimmerer

I found nearly every page of this delightful essay collection incredibly helpful in elucidating the wisdom of Indigenous science and daring to envision a world based on an Indigenous gift economy. I also appreciated the way Kimmerer, a botanist and member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation, interweaves her personal intergenerational healing with community and global healing to be very resonant. I think the links between them are true for all of us, and even more so for those who have experienced the most harm.  

2. The Book of Hope: A Survival Guide for Trying Times by Jane Goodall and Douglas Abrams

Naturalist and primatologist Goodall shares her experiences of hard-won hope in Tanzania and elsewhere—which are often based in listening to the wisdom of local communities so that they can thrive and thereby protect the forest and the chimpanzees.

3. The Overstory by Richard Powers

Nine trees serve as the protagonists of this beautiful novel, with the mighty redwood taking center stage. Most of the human characters, while flawed, are still heartening The underlying theme is for us all to find that inner burning light of inspiration, hold onto it, and begin to act in support of our planet. Ultimately, Powers elicits hope that we can begin again.  

4. Finding the Mother Tree: Discovering the Wisdom of the Forest by Suzanne Simard

This is a phenomenal tale of perseverance, resilience, and humility. A forester in British Columbia, Simard discusses the magic of the mycorrhizal network and the interconnectivity of trees and forest, explaining how trees talk to each other. It is an awe-inspiring example of how little we really know about our natural surroundings. 

5. All We Can Save: Truth, Courage, and Solutions for the Climate Crisis edited by Ayana Elizabeth Johnson and Katharine K. Wilkinson

An important work of intersectional environmentalism, the essays in this collection reveal how racism and environmental destruction go hand-in-hand: both have roots in the same destructive belief that we are truly divided and separated, when, in fact, our collective ability to thrive is intertwined and interdependent. 

6. Chasing Mercury by September Williams

This brilliant love story explores how mercury poisoning and other aspects of environmental justice are inextricably linked to social justice, and features remarkable individuals (many real-life ones are interwoven with Williams’s fictional characters) who give all they’ve got for love of the earth, and each other. 

7. The Land Is Not Empty: Following Jesus in Dismantling the Doctrine of Discovery by Sarah Augustine

This is an incredibly powerful call to action—particularly for Christians—about combating one of the root evils on our planet: the Doctrine of Discovery. A papal bull written in the 1400s that designated land as “empty” unless owned by a Christian monarch, the Doctrine of Discovery is the basis of modern-day land rights and fails to recognize collective Indigenous ownership of land. It’s still cited when extractive industries take Indigenous land, but Augustine has clear ideas about how to put an end to that.

8. My Grandmother's Hands: Racialized Trauma and the Pathway to Mending Our Hearts and Bodies by Resmaa Menakem

Menakem, a therapist, contends that everyone is harmed by racism, and that the trauma manifests in our unconscious physical responses. Luckily, there are ways to change these responses, and he offers impactful somatic exercises we can all use to heal from intergenerational, systemic, and personal wounds.

9. The Divide: Global Inequality from Conquest to Free Markets by Jason Hickel

Hickel provides a brilliant overview of the destructive nature of colonialism and its consequences for the planet, showing how poverty was and is created by systems that benefit the global North. 

10. Lightning Flowers: My Journey to Uncover the Cost of Saving a Life by Katherine Standefer

Standefer, who was implanted with a cardiac defibrillator after being diagnosed with a rare heart condition, pens a poetic and moving memoir about illness, the failings of the American healthcare system, reductionist medicine, and how connected we all are with the natural world. With wires made from metals extracted from the earth forming a tangled knot in her heart (and threatening her very survival), Standefer sees humans and the planet as literally intertwined. 

Climate change since the advent of humans

Series Posts

INDEX

Index - Evolution of Man & Religion

PART I

Bible Civilizations Are a Lot Younger Than Paleo-Human Civilizations

PART II

Climate change since the advent of humans

PART III

In the Days Before Genesis - Part 1, by R.E. Slater

PART IV

In the Days Before Genesis - Part 2, by R.E. Slater

ECO-CIV 1

Healing the Earth and One Another

ECO-CIV 2

Writing A Theology (of Love) for a Nuclear Age (of Brokenness)

* * * * * * * *

How Climate Made History, Pt. 1

From the Ice Age to the Dawn of Humanity

Full Documentary  |  May 26, 2022

Europe, 60.000 BC. Vast ice-sheets grip the land. The populations of Homo sapiens have shrunk to a dangerous low – just a few hundred individuals still eke out a living in the harsh conditions. The climate is anything but stable and repeatedly alternates between warm and cold phases. Elaborate timelapse CGI imagery allows us to witness dramatic changes in the land. Early humans are constantly forced to adapt to the changing conditions and find new food sources. But what is an opportunity for some, spells disaster for others: The Neanderthals were well-adapted to the cold and struggle to adjust as their traditional quarry disappears, while their Homo sapiens competitors triumph over the changes. The shifting climate has made history.

CLIMATE CHANGE SINCE THE ADVENT OF HUMANS

article link

by Stephen T. Jackson

The history of humanity—from the initial appearance of genus Homo over 2,000,000 years ago to the advent and expansion of the modern human species (Homo sapiens) beginning some 150,000 years ago—is integrally linked to climate variation and change. Homo sapiens has experienced nearly two full glacial-interglacial cycles, but its global geographical expansion, massive population increase, cultural diversification, and worldwide ecological domination began only during the last glacial period and accelerated during the last glacial-interglacial transition. The first bipedal apes appeared in a time of climatic transition and variation, and Homo erectus, an extinct species possibly ancestral to modern humans, originated during the colder Pleistocene Epoch and survived both the transition period and multiple glacial-interglacial cycles. Thus, it can be said that climate variation has been the midwife of humanity and its various cultures and civilizations.

Recent glacial and interglacial periods

The most recent glacial phase

With glacial ice restricted to high latitudes and altitudes, Earth 125,000 years ago was in an interglacial period similar to the one occurring today. During the past 125,000 years, however, the Earth system went through an entire glacial-interglacial cycle, only the most recent of many taking place over the last million years. The most recent period of cooling and glaciation began approximately 120,000 years ago. Significant ice sheets developed and persisted over much of Canada and northern Eurasia.

After the initial development of glacial conditions, the Earth system alternated between two modes, one of cold temperatures and growing glaciers and the other of relatively warm temperatures (although much cooler than today) and retreating glaciers. These Dansgaard-Oeschger (DO) cycles, recorded in both ice cores and marine sediments, occurred approximately every 1,500 years. A lower-frequency cycle, called the Bond cycle, is superimposed on the pattern of DO cycles; Bond cycles occurred every 1,400–2,200 years. Each Bond cycle is characterized by unusually cold conditions that take place during the cold phase of a DO cycle, the subsequent Heinrich event (which is a brief dry and cold phase), and the rapid warming phase that follows each Heinrich event. During each Heinrich event, massive fleets of icebergs were released into the North Atlantic, carrying rocks picked up by the glaciers far out to sea. Heinrich events are marked in marine sediments by conspicuous layers of iceberg-transported rock fragments.

Many of the transitions in the DO and Bond cycles were rapid and abrupt, and they are being studied intensely by paleoclimatologists and Earth system scientists to understand the driving mechanisms of such dramatic climatic variations. These cycles now appear to result from interactions between the atmosphere, oceans, ice sheets, and continental rivers that influence thermohaline circulation (the pattern of ocean currents driven by differences in water density, salinity, and temperature, rather than wind). Thermohaline circulation, in turn, controls ocean heat transport, such as the Gulf Stream.

The Last Glacial Maximum

During the past 25,000 years, the Earth system has undergone a series of dramatic transitions. The most recent glacial period peaked 21,500 years ago during the Last Glacial Maximum, or LGM. At that time, the northern third of North America was covered by the Laurentide Ice Sheet, which extended as far south as Des Moines, Iowa; Cincinnati, Ohio; and New York City. The Cordilleran Ice Sheet covered much of western Canada as well as northern Washington, Idaho, and Montana in the United States. In Europe the Scandinavian Ice Sheet sat atop the British Isles, Scandinavia, northeastern Europe, and north-central Siberia. Montane glaciers were extensive in other regions, even at low latitudes in Africa and South America. Global sea level was 125 metres ( 410 feet) below modern levels, because of the long-term net transfer of water from the oceans to the ice sheets. Temperatures near Earth’s surface in unglaciated regions were about 5 °C (9 °F) cooler than today. Many Northern Hemisphere plant and animal species inhabited areas far south of their present ranges. For example, jack pine and white spruce trees grew in northwestern Georgia, 1,000 km (600 miles) south of their modern range limits in the Great Lakes region of North America.

The last deglaciation

Younger Dryas event

The continental ice sheets began to melt back about 20,000 years ago. Drilling and dating of submerged fossil coral reefs provide a clear record of increasing sea levels as the ice melted. The most rapid melting began 15,000 years ago. For example, the southern boundary of the Laurentide Ice Sheet in North America was north of the Great Lakes and St. Lawrence regions by 10,000 years ago, and it had completely disappeared by 6,000 years ago.

The warming trend was punctuated by transient cooling events, most notably the Younger Dryas climate interval of 12,900–11,600 years ago. The climatic regimes that developed during the deglaciation period in many areas, including much of North America, have no modern analog (i.e., no regions exist with comparable seasonal regimes of temperature and moisture). For example, in the interior of North America, climates were much more continental (that is, characterized by warm summers and cold winters) than they are today. Also, paleontological studies indicate assemblages of plant, insect, and vertebrate species that do not occur anywhere today. Spruce trees grew with temperate hardwoods (ash, hornbeam, oak, and elm) in the upper Mississippi River and Ohio River regions. In Alaska, birch and poplar grew in woodlands, and there were very few of the spruce trees that dominate the present-day Alaskan landscape. Boreal and temperate mammals, whose geographic ranges are widely separated today, coexisted in central North America and Russia during this period of deglaciation. These unparalleled climatic conditions probably resulted from the combination of a unique orbital pattern that increased summer insolation and reduced winter insolation in the Northern Hemisphere and the continued presence of Northern Hemisphere ice sheets, which themselves altered atmospheric circulation patterns.

Climate change and the emergence of agriculture

The first known examples of animal domestication occurred in western Asia between 11,000 and 9,500 years ago when goats and sheep were first herded, whereas examples of plant domestication date to 9,000 years ago when wheat, lentils, rye, and barley were first cultivated. This phase of technological increase occurred during a time of climatic transition that followed the last glacial period. A number of scientists have suggested that, although climate change imposed stresses on hunter-gatherer-forager societies by causing rapid shifts in resources, it also provided opportunities as new plant and animal resources appeared.

Glacial and interglacial cycles of the Pleistocene

The glacial period that peaked 21,500 years ago was only the most recent of five glacial periods in the last 450,000 years. In fact, the Earth system has alternated between glacial and interglacial regimes for more than two million years, a period of time known as the Pleistocene. The duration and severity of the glacial periods increased during this period, with a particularly sharp change occurring between 900,000 and 600,000 years ago. Earth is currently within the most recent interglacial period, which started 11,700 years ago and is commonly known as the Holocene Epoch.

The continental glaciations of the Pleistocene left signatures on the landscape in the form of glacial deposits and landforms; however, the best knowledge of the magnitude and timing of the various glacial and interglacial periods comes from oxygen isotope records in ocean sediments. These records provide both a direct measure of sea level and an indirect measure of global ice volume. Water molecules composed of a lighter isotope of oxygen, 16O, are evaporated more readily than molecules bearing a heavier isotope, 18O. Glacial periods are characterized by high 18O concentrations and represent a net transfer of water, especially with 16O, from the oceans to the ice sheets. Oxygen isotope records indicate that interglacial periods have typically lasted 10,000–15,000 years, and maximum glacial periods were of similar length. Most of the past 500,000 years—approximately 80 percent—have been spent within various intermediate glacial states that were warmer than glacial maxima but cooler than interglacials. During these intermediate times, substantial glaciers occurred over much of Canada and probably covered Scandinavia as well. These intermediate states were not constant; they were characterized by continual, millennial-scale climate variation. There has been no average or typical state for global climate during Pleistocene and Holocene times; the Earth system has been in continual flux between interglacial and glacial patterns.

North American ice sheets

European ice sheets

The cycling of the Earth system between glacial and interglacial modes has been ultimately driven by orbital variations. However, orbital forcing is by itself insufficient to explain all of this variation, and Earth system scientists are focusing their attention on the interactions and feedbacks between the myriad components of the Earth system. For example, the initial development of a continental ice sheet increases albedo over a portion of Earth, reducing surface absorption of sunlight and leading to further cooling. Similarly, changes in terrestrial vegetation, such as the replacement of forests by tundra, feed back into the atmosphere via changes in both albedo and latent heat flux from evapotranspiration. Forests—particularly those of tropical and temperate areas, with their large leaf area—release great amounts of water vapour and latent heat through transpiration. Tundra plants, which are much smaller, possess tiny leaves designed to slow water loss; they release only a small fraction of the water vapour that forests do.

The discovery in ice core records that atmospheric concentrations of two potent greenhouse gases, carbon dioxide and methane, have decreased during past glacial periods and peaked during interglacials indicates important feedback processes in the Earth system. Reduction of greenhouse gas concentrations during the transition to a glacial phase would reinforce and amplify cooling already under way. The reverse is true for transition to interglacial periods. The glacial carbon sink remains a topic of considerable research activity. A full understanding of glacial-interglacial carbon dynamics requires knowledge of the complex interplay among ocean chemistry and circulation, ecology of marine and terrestrial organisms, ice sheet dynamics, and atmospheric chemistry and circulation.

The last great cooling

The Earth system has undergone a general cooling trend for the past 50 million years, culminating in the development of permanent ice sheets in the Northern Hemisphere about 2.75 million years ago. These ice sheets expanded and contracted in a regular rhythm, with each glacial maximum separated from adjacent ones by 41,000 years (based on the cycle of axial tilt). As the ice sheets waxed and waned, global climate drifted steadily toward cooler conditions characterized by increasingly severe glaciations and increasingly cool interglacial phases. Beginning around 900,000 years ago, the glacial-interglacial cycles shifted frequency. Ever since, the glacial peaks have been 100,000 years apart, and the Earth system has spent more time in cool phases than before. The 41,000-year periodicity has continued, with smaller fluctuations superimposed on the 100,000-year cycle. In addition, a smaller, 23,000-year cycle has occurred through both the 41,000-year and 100,000-year cycles.

The 23,000-year and 41,000-year cycles are driven ultimately by two components of Earth’s orbital geometry: the equinoctial precession cycle (23,000 years) and the axial-tilt cycle (41,000 years). Although the third parameter of Earth’s orbit, eccentricity, varies on a 100,000-year cycle, its magnitude is insufficient to explain the 100,000-year cycles of glacial and interglacial periods of the past 900,000 years. The origin of the periodicity present in Earth’s eccentricity is an important question in current paleoclimate research.

Climate change through geologic time

The Earth system has undergone dramatic changes throughout its 4.5-billion-year history. These have included climatic changes diverse in mechanisms, magnitudes, rates, and consequences. Many of these past changes are obscure and controversial, and some have been discovered only recently. Nevertheless, the history of life has been strongly influenced by these changes, some of which radically altered the course of evolution. Life itself is implicated as a causative agent of some of these changes, as the processes of photosynthesis and respiration have largely shaped the chemistry of Earth’s atmosphere, oceans, and sediments.

Cenozoic climates

The Cenozoic Era—encompassing the past 66 million years, the time that has elapsed since the mass extinction event marking the end of the Cretaceous Period—has a broad range of climatic variation characterized by alternating intervals of global warming and cooling. Earth has experienced both extreme warmth and extreme cold during this period. These changes have been driven by tectonic forces, which have altered the positions and elevations of the continents as well as ocean passages and bathymetry. Feedbacks between different components of the Earth system (atmosphere, biosphere, lithosphere, cryosphere, and oceans in the hydrosphere) are being increasingly recognized as influences of global and regional climate. In particular, atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide have varied substantially during the Cenozoic for reasons that are poorly understood, though its fluctuation must have involved feedbacks between Earth’s spheres.

Orbital forcing is also evident in the Cenozoic, although, when compared on such a vast era-level timescale, orbital variations can be seen as oscillations against a slowly changing backdrop of lower-frequency climatic trends. Descriptions of the orbital variations have evolved according to the growing understanding of tectonic and biogeochemical changes. A pattern emerging from recent paleoclimatologic studies suggests that the climatic effects of eccentricity, precession, and axial tilt have been amplified during cool phases of the Cenozoic, whereas they have been dampened during warm phases.

The meteor impact that occurred at or very close to the end of the Cretaceous came at a time of global warming, which continued into the early Cenozoic. Tropical and subtropical flora and fauna occurred at high latitudes until at least 40 million years ago, and geochemical records of marine sediments have indicated the presence of warm oceans. The interval of maximum temperature occurred during the late Paleocene and early Eocene epochs (59.2 million to 41.2 million years ago). The highest global temperatures of the Cenozoic occurred during the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM), a short interval lasting approximately 100,000 years. Although the underlying causes are unclear, the onset of the PETM about 56 million years ago was rapid, occurring within a few thousand years, and ecological consequences were large, with widespread extinctions in both marine and terrestrial ecosystems. Sea surface and continental air temperatures increased by more than 5 °C (9 °F) during the transition into the PETM. Sea surface temperatures in the high-latitude Arctic may have been as warm as 23 °C (73 °F), comparable to modern subtropical and warm-temperate seas. Following the PETM, global temperatures declined to pre-PETM levels, but they gradually increased to near-PETM levels over the next few million years during a period known as the Eocene Optimum. This temperature maximum was followed by a steady decline in global temperatures toward the Eocene-Oligocene boundary, which occurred about 33.9 million years ago. These changes are well-represented in marine sediments and in paleontological records from the continents, where vegetation zones moved Equator-ward. Mechanisms underlying the cooling trend are under study, but it is most likely that tectonic movements played an important role. This period saw the gradual opening of the sea passage between Tasmania and Antarctica, followed by the opening of the Drake Passage between South America and Antarctica. The latter, which isolated Antarctica within a cold polar sea, produced global effects on atmospheric and oceanic circulation. Recent evidence suggests that decreasing atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide during this period may have initiated a steady and irreversible cooling trend over the next few million years.

A continental ice sheet developed in Antarctica during the Oligocene Epoch, persisting until a rapid warming event took place 27 million years ago. The late Oligocene and early to mid-Miocene epochs (28.4 million to 13.8 million years ago) were relatively warm, though not nearly as warm as the Eocene. Cooling resumed 15 million years ago, and the Antarctic Ice Sheet expanded again to cover much of the continent. The cooling trend continued through the late Miocene and accelerated into the early Pliocene Epoch, 5.3 million years ago. During this period the Northern Hemisphere remained ice-free, and paleobotanical studies show cool-temperate Pliocene floras at high latitudes on Greenland and the Arctic Archipelago. The Northern Hemisphere glaciation, which began 3.2 million years ago, was driven by tectonic events, such as the closing of the Panama seaway and the uplift of the Andes, the Tibetan Plateau, and western parts of North America. These tectonic events led to changes in the circulation of the oceans and the atmosphere, which in turn fostered the development of persistent ice at high northern latitudes. Small-magnitude variations in carbon dioxide concentrations, which had been relatively low since at least the mid-Oligocene (27.8 million years ago), are also thought to have contributed to this glaciation.

Phanerozoic climates

The Phanerozoic Eon (541 million years ago to the present), which includes the entire span of complex, multicellular life on Earth, has witnessed an extraordinary array of climatic states and transitions. The sheer antiquity of many of these regimes and events renders them difficult to understand in detail. However, a number of periods and transitions are well known, owing to good geological records and intense study by scientists. Furthermore, a coherent pattern of low-frequency climatic variation is emerging, in which the Earth system alternates between warm (“greenhouse”) phases and cool (“icehouse”) phases. The warm phases are characterized by high temperatures, high sea levels, and an absence of continental glaciers. Cool phases in turn are marked by low temperatures, low sea levels, and the presence of continental ice sheets, at least at high latitudes. Superimposed on these alternations are higher-frequency variations, where cool periods are embedded within greenhouse phases and warm periods are embedded within icehouse phases. For example, glaciers developed for a brief period (between 1 million and 10 million years) during the late Ordovician and early Silurian, in the middle of the early Paleozoic greenhouse phase (541 million to about 359 million years ago). Similarly, warm periods with glacial retreat occurred within the late Cenozoic cool period during the late Oligocene and early Miocene epochs.

The Earth system has been in an icehouse phase for the past 30 million to 35 million years, ever since the development of ice sheets on Antarctica. The previous major icehouse phase occurred between about 359 million and about 252 million years ago, during the Carboniferous and Permian periods of the late Paleozoic Era. Glacial sediments dating to this period have been identified in much of Africa as well as in the Arabian Peninsula, South America, Australia, India, and Antarctica. At the time, all these regions were part of Gondwana, a high-latitude supercontinent in the Southern Hemisphere. The glaciers atop Gondwana extended to at least 45° S latitude, similar to the latitude reached by Northern Hemisphere ice sheets during the Pleistocene. Some late Paleozoic glaciers extended even further Equator-ward—to 35° S. One of the most striking features of this time period are cyclothems, repeating sedimentary beds of alternating sandstone, shale, coal, and limestone. The great coal deposits of North America’s Appalachian region, the American Midwest, and northern Europe are interbedded in these cyclothems, which may represent repeated transgressions (producing limestone) and retreats (producing shales and coals) of ocean shorelines in response to orbital variations.

The two most prominent warm phases in Earth history occurred during the Mesozoic and early Cenozoic eras (approximately 252 million to 35 million years ago) and the early and mid-Paleozoic (approximately 500 million to about 359 million years ago). Climates of each of these greenhouse periods were distinct; continental positions and ocean bathymetry were very different, and terrestrial vegetation was absent from the continents until relatively late in the Paleozoic warm period. Both of these periods experienced substantial long-term climate variation and change; increasing evidence indicates brief glacial episodes during the mid-Mesozoic.

Understanding the mechanisms underlying icehouse-greenhouse dynamics is an important area of research, involving an interchange between geologic records and the modeling of the Earth system and its components. Two processes have been implicated as drivers of Phanerozoic climate change. First, tectonic forces caused changes in the positions and elevations of continents and the bathymetry of oceans and seas. Second, variations in greenhouse gases were also important drivers of climate, though at these long timescales they were largely controlled by tectonic processes, in which sinks and sources of greenhouse gases varied.

Climates of early Earth

The pre-Phanerozoic interval, also known as Precambrian time, comprises some 88 percent of the time elapsed since the origin of Earth. The pre-Phanerozoic is a poorly understood phase of Earth system history. Much of the sedimentary record of the atmosphere, oceans, biota, and crust of the early Earth has been obliterated by erosion, metamorphosis, and subduction. However, a number of pre-Phanerozoic records have been found in various parts of the world, mainly from the later portions of the period. Pre-Phanerozoic Earth system history is an extremely active area of research, in part because of its importance in understanding the origin and early evolution of life on Earth. Furthermore, the chemical composition of Earth’s atmosphere and oceans largely developed during this period, with living organisms playing an active role. Geologists, paleontologists, microbiologists, planetary geologists, atmospheric scientists, and geochemists are focusing intense efforts on understanding this period. Three areas of particular interest and debate are the “faint young Sun paradox,” the role of organisms in shaping Earth’s atmosphere, and the possibility that Earth went through one or more “snowball” phases of global glaciation.

Faint young Sun paradox

Astrophysical studies indicate that the luminosity of the Sun was much lower during Earth’s early history than it has been in the Phanerozoic. In fact, radiative output was low enough to suggest that all surface water on Earth should have been frozen solid during its early history, but evidence shows that it was not. The solution to this “faint young Sun paradox” appears to lie in the presence of unusually high concentrations of greenhouse gases at the time, particularly methane and carbon dioxide. As solar luminosity gradually increased through time, concentrations of greenhouse gases would have to have been much higher than today. This circumstance would have caused Earth to heat up beyond life-sustaining levels. Therefore, greenhouse gas concentrations must have decreased proportionally with increasing solar radiation, implying a feedback mechanism to regulate greenhouse gases. One of these mechanisms might have been rock weathering, which is temperature-dependent and serves as an important sink for, rather than source of, carbon dioxide by removing sizable amounts of this gas from the atmosphere. Scientists are also looking to biological processes (many of which also serve as carbon dioxide sinks) as complementary or alternative regulating mechanisms of greenhouse gases on the young Earth.

Photosynthesis and atmospheric chemistry

The evolution by photosynthetic bacteria of a new photosynthetic pathway, substituting water (H2O) for hydrogen sulfide (H2S) as a reducing agent for carbon dioxide, had dramatic consequences for Earth system geochemistry. Molecular oxygen (O2) is given off as a by-product of photosynthesis using the H2O pathway, which is energetically more efficient than the more primitive H2S pathway. Using H2O as a reducing agent in this process led to the large-scale deposition of banded-iron formations, or BIFs, a source of 90 percent of present-day iron ores. Oxygen present in ancient oceans oxidized dissolved iron, which precipitated out of solution onto the ocean floors. This deposition process, in which oxygen was used up as fast as it was produced, continued for millions of years until most of the iron dissolved in the oceans was precipitated. By approximately 2 billion years ago, oxygen was able to accumulate in dissolved form in seawater and to outgas to the atmosphere. Although oxygen does not have greenhouse gas properties, it plays important indirect roles in Earth’s climate, particularly in phases of the carbon cycle. Scientists are studying the role of oxygen and other contributions of early life to the development of the Earth system.

Snowball Earth hypothesis

Geochemical and sedimentary evidence indicates that Earth experienced as many as four extreme cooling events between 750 million and 580 million years ago. Geologists have proposed that Earth’s oceans and land surfaces were covered by ice from the poles to the Equator during these events. This “Snowball Earth” hypothesis is a subject of intense study and discussion. Two important questions arise from this hypothesis. First, how, once frozen, could Earth thaw? Second, how could life survive periods of global freezing? A proposed solution to the first question involves the outgassing of massive amounts of carbon dioxide by volcanoes, which could have warmed the planetary surface rapidly, especially given that major carbon dioxide sinks (rock weathering and photosynthesis) would have been dampened by a frozen Earth. A possible answer to the second question may lie in the existence of present-day life-forms within hot springs and deep-sea vents, which would have persisted long ago despite the frozen state of Earth’s surface.

A counter-premise known as the “Slushball Earth” hypothesis contends that Earth was not completely frozen over. Rather, in addition to massive ice sheets covering the continents, parts of the planet (especially ocean areas near the Equator) could have been draped only by a thin, watery layer of ice amid areas of open sea. Under this scenario, photosynthetic organisms in low-ice or ice-free regions could continue to capture sunlight efficiently and survive these periods of extreme cold.

Abrupt climate changes in Earth history

An important new area of research, abrupt climate change, has developed since the 1980s. This research has been inspired by the discovery, in the ice core records of Greenland and Antarctica, of evidence for abrupt shifts in regional and global climates of the past. These events, which have also been documented in ocean and continental records, involve sudden shifts of Earth’s climate system from one equilibrium state to another. Such shifts are of considerable scientific concern because they can reveal something about the controls and sensitivity of the climate system. In particular, they point out nonlinearities, the so-called “tipping points,” where small, gradual changes in one component of the system can lead to a large change in the entire system. Such nonlinearities arise from the complex feedbacks between components of the Earth system. For example, during the Younger Dryas event (see below) a gradual increase in the release of fresh water to the North Atlantic Ocean led to an abrupt shutdown of the thermohaline circulation in the Atlantic basin. Abrupt climate shifts are of great societal concern, for any such shifts in the future might be so rapid and radical as to outstrip the capacity of agricultural, ecological, industrial, and economic systems to respond and adapt. Climate scientists are working with social scientists, ecologists, and economists to assess society’s vulnerability to such “climate surprises.”

The Younger Dryas event (12,900 to 11,600 years ago) is the most intensely studied and best-understood example of abrupt climate change. The event took place during the last deglaciation, a period of global warming when the Earth system was in transition from a glacial mode to an interglacial one. The Younger Dryas was marked by a sharp drop in temperatures in the North Atlantic region; cooling in northern Europe and eastern North America is estimated at 4 to 8 °C (7.2 to 14.4 °F). Terrestrial and marine records indicate that the Younger Dryas had detectable effects of lesser magnitude over most other regions of Earth. The termination of the Younger Dryas was very rapid, occurring within a decade. The Younger Dryas resulted from an abrupt shutdown of the thermohaline circulation in the North Atlantic, which is critical for the transport of heat from equatorial regions northward (today the Gulf Stream is a part of that circulation). The cause of the shutdown of the thermohaline circulation is under study; an influx of large volumes of freshwater from melting glaciers into the North Atlantic has been implicated, although other factors probably played a role.

Paleoclimatologists are devoting increasing attention to identifying and studying other abrupt changes. The Dansgaard-Oeschger cycles of the last glacial period are now recognized as representing alternation between two climate states, with rapid transitions from one state to the other. A 200-year-long cooling event in the Northern Hemisphere approximately 8,200 years ago resulted from the rapid draining of glacial Lake Agassiz into the North Atlantic via the Great Lakes and St. Lawrence drainage. This event, characterized as a miniature version of the Younger Dryas, had ecological impacts in Europe and North America that included a rapid decline of hemlock populations in New England forests. In addition, evidence of another such transition, marked by a rapid drop in the water levels of lakes and bogs in eastern North America, occurred 5,200 years ago. It is recorded in ice cores from glaciers at high altitudes in tropical regions as well as tree-ring, lake-level, and peatland samples from temperate regions.

Abrupt climatic changes occurring before the Pleistocene have also been documented. A transient thermal maximum has been documented near the Paleocene-Eocene boundary (56 million years ago), and evidence of rapid cooling events are observed near the boundaries between both the Eocene and Oligocene epochs (33.9 million years ago) and the Oligocene and Miocene epochs (23 million years ago). All three of these events had global ecological, climatic, and biogeochemical consequences. Geochemical evidence indicates that the warm event occurring at the Paleocene-Eocene boundary was associated with a rapid increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations, possibly resulting from the massive outgassing and oxidation of methane hydrates (a compound whose chemical structure traps methane within a lattice of ice) from the ocean floor. The two cooling events appear to have resulted from a transient series of positive feedbacks among the atmosphere, oceans, ice sheets, and biosphere, similar to those observed in the Pleistocene. Other abrupt changes, such as the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum, are recorded at various points in the Phanerozoic.

Abrupt climate changes can evidently be caused by a variety of processes. Rapid changes in an external factor can push the climate system into a new mode. Outgassing of methane hydrates and the sudden influx of glacial meltwater into the ocean are examples of such external forcing. Alternatively, gradual changes in external factors can lead to the crossing of a threshold; the climate system is unable to return to the former equilibrium and passes rapidly to a new one. Such nonlinear system behaviour is a potential concern as human activities, such as fossil-fuel combustion and land-use change, alter important components of Earth’s climate system.

See how climate change affects marine ecosystems  |  See all videos for this article

Humans and other species have survived countless climatic changes in the past, and humans are a notably adaptable species. Adjustment to climatic changes, whether it is biological (as in the case of other species) or cultural (for humans), is easiest and least catastrophic when the changes are gradual and can be anticipated to large extent. Rapid changes are more difficult to adapt to and incur more disruption and risk. Abrupt changes, especially unanticipated climate surprises, put human cultures and societies, as well as both the populations of other species and the ecosystems they inhabit, at considerable risk of severe disruption. Such changes may well be within humanity’s capacity to adapt, but not without paying severe penalties in the form of economic, ecological, agricultural, human health, and other disruptions. Knowledge of past climate variability provides guidelines on the natural variability and sensitivity of the Earth system. This knowledge also helps identify the risks associated with altering the Earth system with greenhouse gas emissions and regional to global-scale changes in land cover.