Former United States president Donald Trump's photo op at St. John's Church has been described as following the "playbook of authoritarian-leaning leaders the world over". |
Constitution of the United States - The First AmendmentCongress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
Authoritarianism has entered the Church; but not in a good way...
by R.E. Slater
This morning's news of Michael Flynn's extremist speech last night at a radical right rally in San Antonio, Texas, is cause for concern to all Christians and Churches teaching an openness of dialogue, irenic critique of beliefs amid doctrinal tenents, and welcoming of all religions different from themselves as is proper in an expanding, polyplural, civil democracy of the 21st Century.
However, under the recent Trumpian era of gaslighting fundamental and conservative evangelical Christian churches, white religious nationalism (aka, white supremacy) has gained a new traction in American churches once content in arguing doctrine with one another rather than attacking the democratic institutions of the United States of America as expressed in the Constitution's First Amendment Rights.
The church in the past twenty years has changed. And not in a good way. For those interested in see how these changes have taken place I have put together a complete podcast series of 14 discussions held by Tripp Fuller with Diana Butler Bass and Brian McLaren this past Fall. All these speakers (and friends), like myself, were at one time part of the fundamental / conservative evangelical church, but have now transition to a wake-up call in Jesus to step away from any self-referential belief systems into a more expansive, and tolerant, progressive Christian frame of mind where beliefs and dogmas might be discussed more patiently with one another.
R.E. Slater
November 15, 2021
News References
November 14, 2021
MarketWatch -
Google Search - Extremist Authoritarianism in the Church
One may also add multiple examples in European history of both Catholic and Protestant authoritarianism |
Religion and Authoritarianism
Most measures of religiosity, such as church attendance and affiliation, are positively correlated with the authoritarian personality cluster, which includes submission to authority, conventionality, and intolerance of out-groups. The correlation is especially strong between religious fundamentalism (defined as belief in an "inerrant set of religious teachings") and authoritarianism, both of which are characterized by low openness to experience, high rigidity, and low cognitive complexity. In particular, authoritarianism "is positively associated with a religion that is conventional, unquestioned, and unreflective".
Background
United States president Donald Trump's photo op at St. John's Church has been described as following the "playbook of authoritarian-leaning leaders the world over".
Hundreds of scientific articles have been published investigating the connections between religion and authoritarianism. There is a distinction between psychology, which treats authoritarianism as innate to the personality, and sociology, which considers authoritarianism a result of one's environment and posits that it may be influenced by factors such as religion.
A longitudinal study of Americans born in the 1920s found that this effect held for traditional church-centered religion but not for those that are seeking non-institutional spirituality. The latter mode of religion is "characterized by an openness to new experiences and by creativity and experimentation, characteristics that are antithetical to the conventionality that adheres in authoritarianism".
* * * * * * * * * *
I've been finding Tripp's 14 or so podcasts on white authoritarian religious groups very relevant. These past recent years has shown to America the highly uncivil rhetoric and radical nationalism which has swept up the greater part of evangelicalism. If you, like myself, are finding yourself at a greater and greater distance from your church, family and friends, this is why.
Theo-Politicism has swept into the church and neatly divided 30% of us from our present fellowships. In these podcasts Diana has been tasked with reporting from the Pew Surveys and PRRI surveys issued recently during the discussions (the ones I listed not long ago that are always available to the public)....
Diana's religious focus is on reporting on the history of the contemporary Christian church as a religious sociologist who participates with these surveys on a regular basis and has written many books and blog articles over the years based upon her findings. You may also walk with her weekly on her website, "The Cottage".
R.E. Slater
November 15, 2021
You may subscribe free of charge -
diana's podcasts -
https://dianabutlerbass.com/online/
https://dianabutlerbass.com/online/
also check youtube for more of diana's podcasts -
https://www.youtube.com/results...
https://www.youtube.com/results...
and of course anything tripp fuller -
https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=tripp+fuller
https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=tripp+fuller
Homebrewed Christianity -
https://www.youtube.com/results...
https://www.youtube.com/results...
tripp's site -
https://trippfuller.com/
https://trippfuller.com/
mine own site -
https://relevancy22.blogspot.com/
https://relevancy22.blogspot.com/
* * * * * * * *
Tripp Fuller Live Streaming W/ Diana Butler Bass
Jun 16, 2021
with Brian McLaren & Diana Butler Bass
Aug 25, 2021
Session 1
20 Years of Religious Decline
Aug 31, 2021
Session 2
The Rise of Authoritarianism
Sep 7, 2021
Q&A - Session 2
with Brian McLaren & Tripp Fuller
Sep 8, 2021
Session 3
Repentance and Resistance
Sep 14, 2021
Q&A - Session 3
with Diana Butler Bass & Tripp Fuller
Sep 16, 2021
Theology and Spirituality in a Time of Rupture
Sep 21, 2021
Q&A - Session 4
with Diana Butler Bass & Tripp Fuller
Sep 23, 2021
Session 5
Inter-Religious Learning w/ Brian McLaren
Sep 28, 2021
Q&A - Session 5
with Brian McLaren & Tripp Fuller
Sep 30, 2021
TheoCon Presentation by Brian McLaren
Should I Stay or Should I Go?
with Diana Bass, Brian McLaren, and Tripp Fuller
Oct 5, 2021
Moral Injury & the War on Terror
with Army Chaplain Dr. Josh Morris
Sep 9, 2021