What are the sacred texts of major religions?
- Islam - The Quran & Hadith
- Hinduism - The Vedas
- Judaism - The Tanakh & Talmoud
- Buddhism - The Tripitaka
- Christianity - The Holy Bible
- Taoism - The Tao Te Ching
Between major world religions like Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, and Taoism, monks from long-forgotten ages worked diligently to ensure the versions we carry today. They hoped to maintain these texts to accurately represent the histories and faiths of cultures and civilizations that now exist only in their modern-day descendants.
Thursday, January 16, 2025
What to do with Sacred Texts and Evolving Faiths? Part 1
Christianity, Islam, Judaism
* * * * * * * *
Part 1 was an introduction to how (i) the Canon of the Bible was collected through the historical Old and New Testament centuries of Israel and the early Church; and, (ii) how to read the ancient Hebrew and Greek texts of that gathered Biblical Canon. Having a rich, personal history, of quality Church Sunday Schools; a fairly deep Bible minor from a traditional private Baptist College; and a four-year Graduate Masters of Divinity degree from that same college's Seminary, Part 1 was for me a dense summary of those Christian years. I hope it helps those curious to how the Bible and it's texts came to be.
In Part 2 I have taken the past several series at Relevancy22 utilizing our studies in (i) process-based Axiology (Dec 2024) and (ii) process-based Philosophy (Jan 2025) to (iii) ratchet-up these studies towards a process-based Christian speculation of how the Bible could be approached and read. It's what I have come to lately come to consider as "The Evolving Setting of the Christian Bible". But this would also include the "Evolving Setting of all Sacred Texts" of all major global religions. That is, what is good for one faith is good for all.
Coming to this kind of theological proposition has been a hard task for me as it leaves many things unwisely open from those who carrying forms of spiritual baggage different from my own. For me, it's taken some time to lay aside my traditional Christian heritage-and-education steeped in the ingrained belief that the Bible is God's last-and-only written word to humanity. I've had to expand my idea of "Biblical Inspiration" over the years in order to come to my more recent thoughts expressed here below.
And as you'll soon see, it is the right choice to make and the correct course to pursue. I have come to like the kind of God my new process faith has come to embrace and dislike the kind of God my traditional faith had taught (sic, reference the previous series in Axiology and Process Philosophy).
Why? For some time I haven't liked the church's perceptions of the human character, nor the world or creation at large, nor even it's kind of Christ it believes in. It's interpretation of the Bible and its view of God leaves a lot lacking. And just because the bible says things about God and people doesn't mean that its authors and writers were correct in their "inspired assessments". It more simply means they were expressing their belief about God and their faith as much as we are today.
I explain all of this further below. But you should also know that my faith in Christ is as solid as ever - even more so - though my approach to "Christianized" theology reserves the right to reject that which isn't loving nor Christian in my opinion. See what you think...
R.E. Slater
January 16, 2025
* * * * * * * *
Observation 1
Assume God did not inspire or author the Bible. Instead, (1) approach the subject of God and faith as an evolving iterative, reflective, learning process of searching for God and faith as part of the human journey.
The New Testament Canon, Manuscripts, & Textual Transmission, Part 1
Studies on the New Testament Canon,
Manuscripts, & Textual Transmission
Part 1
by R.E. Slater & ChatGPT
Important References to Read - Part 1:
by Bart D. Ehrman | Nov 8, 2022
Misquoting Jesus Podcast with Bart Ehrman
In this episode, Megan and Bart discuss the "origin of the canon," meaning: who chose the books that made it into the Bible, and why did they choose these 27?" They address related issues, such as:
- Books, letters, and gospels that were considered authoritative by some early Christians, but were ultimately rejected on one basis or another;
- Early New Testament manuscripts that actually DO contain some rejected texts;
- Criteria that were used to determine which texts to include;
- Proto-orthodox church fathers and their influence;
- What information early church fathers did--and did not--have to base their decisions on.
* * * * * *
Observation 1
Comment on Bruce Metzger's, The Text of the New Testament: Its Transmission, Corruption, and Restoration, Edition 4
ChatGPT
Bruce M. Metzger - The Text of the New Testament: Its Transmission, Corruption, and Restoration (4th Edition)
This authoritative work by Bruce Metzger, revised and expanded with contributions from Bart D. Ehrman, remains a foundational text for studying the textual history of the New Testament. Here's a brief overview of its significance and key features:
Overview:
- Author: Bruce M. Metzger (with Bart D. Ehrman)
- Edition: 4th
- Published by: Oxford University Press
- Focus: The history, transmission, textual criticism, and restoration of the New Testament texts.
Key Themes and Content:
Textual Transmission:
- Explores how New Testament manuscripts were copied, preserved, and disseminated across centuries.
- Details the challenges posed by scribal errors and the materials (e.g., papyrus, parchment) used for transmission.
Corruption of Texts:
- Discusses unintentional (e.g., slips of the pen) and intentional alterations (e.g., theological edits) in the manuscripts.
- Highlights examples of significant textual variants and their implications for interpretation.
Restoration through Textual Criticism:
- Introduces methods of textual criticism, including external and internal evidence.
- Provides insights into reconstructing the earliest attainable form of the text.
Manuscript Evidence:
- Reviews the most important manuscripts (e.g., Codex Sinaiticus, Codex Vaticanus).
- Considers the role of ancient versions (e.g., Syriac, Latin) and patristic citations.
Impact of Discoveries:
- Reflects on significant manuscript discoveries, including the Dead Sea Scrolls and Oxyrhynchus papyri.
- Analyzes their impact on understanding the New Testament text.
Modern Editions of the Greek New Testament:
- Explores critical editions such as Nestle-Aland and the United Bible Societies (UBS) texts.
- Examines the methodologies and apparatuses behind these editions.
Why It’s Essential:
- Scholarly Rigor: Metzger's expertise provides a meticulous, well-researched foundation for understanding New Testament textual criticism.
- Accessibility: Balances scholarly depth with readability, making it suitable for both students and specialists.
- Updates in the 4th Edition: Bart D. Ehrman’s contributions reflect advancements in the field since earlier editions.
This book is indispensable for anyone interested in the textual reliability and history of the New Testament, from seminarians to seasoned textual critics. Would you like to delve deeper into any specific section or theme?
Observation 2
List most recent + comprehensive studies of the same content...
ChatGPT
Building upon Bruce M. Metzger's foundational work, several recent and comprehensive studies have advanced the field of New Testament textual criticism. Notable among these are:
An Introduction to the New Testament Manuscripts and Their Texts
Authored by D.C. Parker and published by Cambridge University Press in 2008, this work offers a unique perspective by placing manuscripts and their varying texts at the forefront. It provides a comprehensive overview of the codex form, manuscript traditions in various languages, palaeography, and practical skills for studying these texts.
The Text of the New Testament in Contemporary Research: Essays on the Status Quaestionis
Edited by Bart D. Ehrman and Michael W. Holmes, this second edition, published by Brill, compiles 24 essays by internationally acknowledged experts. It provides an up-to-date assessment of every major aspect of New Testament textual criticism, discussing advances made since the mid-20th century.
Studies in the Theory and Method of New Testament Textual Criticism
Co-authored by Eldon Jay Epp and Gordon D. Fee, this volume presents 17 studies offering a comprehensive assessment of past and current methods applied to the New Testament text. It includes critiques of current theories, methods of establishing textual relationships, and guidelines for using patristic evidence.
Recent Developments in New Testament Textual Criticism
Authored by H.A.G. Houghton and published in 'Early Christianity' in 2011, this article provides an overview of recent advancements in the field, including the impact of digital tools and methodologies on textual criticism.
Editio Critica Maior (ECM)
An ongoing project by the Institute for New Testament Textual Research, the ECM aims to produce a comprehensive critical edition of the Greek New Testament. Utilizing the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM), it documents the textual tradition of the New Testament across Greek manuscripts, translations, and ancient citations.
These works collectively contribute to a deeper understanding of the transmission, variation, and restoration of New Testament texts, reflecting the dynamic nature of textual criticism in contemporary scholarship.
Observation 3
Second subject area. Bruce M. Metzger The Canon of the New Testament: Its Origin, Development, and Significance
ChatGPT
Bruce M. Metzger - The Canon of the New Testament: Its Origin, Development, and Significance
This seminal work by Bruce M. Metzger examines the historical process behind the formation of the New Testament canon, exploring the factors that influenced the inclusion and exclusion of certain books.
Overview:
- Author: Bruce M. Metzger
- Published by: Clarendon Press, 1987
- Focus: The origin, development, and significance of the New Testament canon.
Key Themes and Content:
Historical Context:
- Examines the early Christian community's writings and how they were preserved, read, and shared.
- Discusses the social, theological, and political factors that shaped the development of the canon.
The Canonization Process:
- Explores the criteria used to determine which books were considered authoritative (e.g., apostolic origin, orthodoxy, widespread usage).
- Traces the stages of canon formation, from early collections to the final lists recognized by church councils.
Excluded Texts:
- Analyzes non-canonical works such as the Gospel of Thomas, Gospel of Peter, and other apocryphal writings.
- Discusses why these texts were excluded and their impact on the Christian tradition.
Key Historical Figures:
- Explores the roles of individuals like Irenaeus, Athanasius, and Eusebius in shaping the canon.
- Examines controversies surrounding specific books (e.g., Hebrews, Revelation, James).
Theological Significance:
- Reflects on the canon's role in defining orthodoxy and guiding Christian faith and practice.
- Discusses the interplay between the canon and the doctrine of inspiration.
Impact of Discoveries:
- Highlights the significance of manuscript discoveries, such as the Nag Hammadi texts, in understanding early Christian diversity.
Modern Perspectives:
- Considers how modern textual criticism and historical research have influenced the understanding of the canon.
Why It’s Essential:
Metzger's work is a thorough and insightful exploration of how the New Testament canon came to be. It balances scholarly detail with accessibility, making it a foundational text for anyone studying the historical and theological development of the Christian scriptures.
Recent Studies on the Canon of the New Testament
To complement Metzger's work, consider these more recent and comprehensive studies:
Michael J. Kruger - The Question of Canon: Challenging the Status Quo in the New Testament Debate
- Explores the historical, theological, and sociological aspects of the canon debate.
- Challenges traditional assumptions about how the New Testament canon developed.
Lee Martin McDonald - The Biblical Canon: Its Origin, Transmission, and Authority
- Provides a detailed history of both Old and New Testament canons.
- Discusses canonical formation from a comparative perspective.
John Barton - A History of the Bible: The Book and Its Faiths
- Examines the Bible's history as a text, including the process of canonization.
- Discusses how various faith traditions understand and interpret the canon.
Craig D. Allert - A High View of Scripture? The Authority of the Bible and the Formation of the New Testament Canon
- Investigates the authority of scripture in light of its historical formation.
J. B. Lightfoot et al. - The Apostolic Fathers (Vol. 1 and 2)
- Offers valuable insights into the early Christian writings that influenced the formation of the canon.
These works, alongside Metzger's foundational study, provide a comprehensive understanding of the New Testament canon's formation and significance. Would you like further details on any of these texts?
Observation Last
Thank you. Let's totle this discuss as "The Evolving Setting of the Bible."
ChatGPT
The discussion has been saved under the title "The Evolving Setting of the Bible." Let me know if there's anything else you'd like to add or explore further!